Are you concerned about rough skin, or that your skin isn't getting enough moisture? Japanese peeling gels, otherwise known as exfoliating gels or gommages gently exfoliate dead skin and can help reduce dryness, remove grime from pores, and can brighten up the skin. However, there are a ton of brands, like Rosette, FANCL, and PLuS, all being sold at varying price points. On top of that, there are a lot of exfoliating gels with acronyms like BHA, AHA, PHA, and other difficult ingredients that it almost feels like you need a degree in chemistry to even begin to understand what to look for.
To find out which was the best Japanese exfoliators, we gathered 10 of the best-selling products on e-commerce sites popular in Japan, such as Amazon, Rakuten, Yahoo! Shopping, and @cosme Shopping and put all of the products to the test to find out which was the best Japanese peeling gel.
We tested each exfoliating gel for the following:
Keep on reading to find out more about the 10 best Japanese exfoliating gels!
Emiko Akahoshi has worked in the cosmetics industry for 19 years. Through her time at two major cosmetics manufacturers, as well as working at an organic cosmetics manufacturer where she was involved in the launch of a new cosmetics business, which includes planning, development, and the management of the manufacturing of organic cosmetics, Emiko has gained an incredible amount of experience and knowledge of the industry. Currently, Emiko is the CEO of ELATE COSME WORKS (https://elatecosmeworks.com/), a consulting company that helps those who want to manufacture OEM cosmetics as well as those who want to launch their own cosmetics business. Follow her on Twitter @emiposhi and on Instagram @emi.elatecosmeworks for information related to all-things cosmetics, including the business side of the industry.
mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.
Experts featured in this article only reviewed the content of our buying guide. They had no part in the selection or ranking of products or services listed.
The products and services listed are ranked independently by the editorial team based on 10 Best Japanese Peeling Gels (as of 11-04-2022).
Japanese exfoliators, sometimes referred to as Japanese peeling gels or gomagges (that's French for "scrub" or "exfoliate"), are products that utilize chemical or physical exfoliants to remove dead skin cells, and don't literally peel the skin.
Our skin stays healthy to a convenient function called turnover, where dead skin cells are shed and replaced by new skin cells in a process called desquamation. While this can take anywhere from 1 to 2 months for your skin to complete its turnover cycle, irregular lifestyles or stress can disrupt this turnover cycle.
Old skin cells that haven't been properly shed can lead to dry skin, roughness, blackheads, as well as acne, so it's important to use an exfoliator and help the turnover process.
Japanese peeling gels work by massaging the gel onto your skin. As you do this, the gel changes texture, turning into little lumpy balls. Those balls gently exfoliate your skin, picking up dead skin cells and excess sebum along the way.
In this section, we'll break down the four major points to consider when looking for an effective Japanese exfoliating gel.
Broadly speaking, there are three types of exfoliants: BHAs, AHAs, and PHAs.
BHAs, like salicylic acid, are easily dissolved in oil, and is best for those who want to care of dead skin cells that are clogged in the pores.
AHAs like glycolic acid, lactic acid, and citric acid, to name a few, as well as PHAs like gluconolactone and lactobionic acid, are easily dissolved in water, and are best for removing grime and dead skin cells on the surface of the skin.
Always check the ingredients list to see if the exfoliating gel has the exfoliating ingredients best suited for your concerns.
Next, consider what moisturizing ingredients the exfoliating gel is formulated with.
Since exfoliating gels are rinsed off, it might seem pointless for them to contain moisturizing ingredients, but they're an important ingredient, since they minimize dryness after you rinse it off as well as irritation caused by the exfoliating ingredients.
Look for a product that lists glycerin, DPG, honey, or plant extracts for the most moisturizing Japanese exfoliating gels.
Note that if a products formulated with a large amount of plant extracts can irritate sensitive skin, so know that more isn't necessarily better.
How an exfoliating gel feels is also incredibly important.
Watery exfoliating gels tend to drip off when you put it on your face. Gels that are thick in texture won't immediately drip off and are much easier to handle.
Moreover, watery exfoliating gels not only tend to drip off, but also provide less of a barrier on your skin, feeling almost like you're directly rubbing your skin. Thicker gels feel softer on the skin and can reduce friction.
There are some exfoliating gels that can be used even when your hands are wet.
If you want to exfoliate your entire body or want to exfoliate in the bath, we recommend products that you can use with wet hands, since you won't have to wipe your hands beforehand.
$9.45
Meishoku Cosmetics' DET Clear Bright & Peel Peeling Jelly Mixed Fruit Scent is a Japanese peeling gel that can be found at most drugstores in Japan. Since it can be used with wet hands, you can exfoliate your skin while in the bath as well.
In addition to fruit and plant extracts, this peeling gel was formulated with malic acid, tartaric acid, and salicylic acid, meaning it was incredibly exfoliating.
When we used our corneum checker to compare the amount of dead skin before and after using the product, we that on average, it removed about 60% of dead skin cells, earning it high marks for exfoliation.
While some of our testers commented that as they worked in the peeling gel, it started feeling a bit squeaky, so this may not be the best for those who seek an exfoliant that can make their skin feel dewy and soft. Still, they were thrilled by how smooth it made the skin feel, making it a great product for its exfoliating ability and smooth finish.
$12.53
Beaute De Mode's Nice & Quick Botanical Peeling Gel comes in a large bottle with plenty to use.
This exfoliant contains AHAs like glycolic acid and lactic acid, earning it an above-average score in the ingredients test.
In our exfoliation test, we found the results to be mixed, with some seeing 90% of their dead skin cells removed, while others actually saw an increase in dead skin cells.
Exfoliating too frequently on skin that doesn't have that much dead skin on it can actually disrupt your turnover cycle even more. While some products recommend you exfoliate 1 to 2 times a week, it's best to stick to a frequency that best suits your skin.
This peeling gel comes in a large bottle, so it's a great size to keep at home. Plus, we liked how the thicker gel meant that it didn't drip off our hands, which made it easy to use.
$6.99
Rosette's Rosette Gommage is another Japanese exfoliant that can be found at drugstores across the country.
It has three types of AHAs: lactic acid, malic acid, and citric acid, which are all great exfoliants. However, it does contain ethanol, so those who are sensitive to products with alcohol need to take caution, but this otherwise earned a decent score in the ingredients test.
When we actually used this product, while some testers found 90% of their dead skin removed, there were still others that actually saw an increase in dead skin. If you don't have that much dead skin, it might be best to not use this so frequently.
While it's a watery gel, it doesn't make the skin feel tight. Additionally, the cap had a decently firm feel to it, with testers commenting that the product feels easy to use.
$33.42
Style Create's PLuS Honey Mild Peeling Gel is formulated with honey to help moisturize while exfoliating.
In the feel test, our testers commented their skin felt smooth and soft without feeling dry. The gel is on the watery side, so it is prone to dripping, but this shouldn't be a problem when using it on the face.
When we compared before and after using the exfoliant, we found that some of our testers saw a 70% reduction in dead skin, making it ideal for those who have rough skin.
Formulated with malic and citric acid, the ingredients chart alone suggested this product has superior exfoliating properties.
$31.28
est commu's Derpharm Epiderm Gel 7 is an exfoliant that the brand recommends using together with its Enzyme Gel.
Featuring BHAs like salicylic acid and AHAs like lactic acid and glycolic acid, it not only removes dead skin cells on the surface of the skin, but also is great at removing sebum and skin cells lodged deep in the pores.
Since it doesn't contain cationic surfactants often found in other exfoliants for a smoother finish, our testers commented that their skin felt more moist, rather than smooth.
Since this exfoliant is formulated with ethanol, those who are sensitive to alcohol should take caution, but this is otherwise a great product for those who don't like having their skin feel excessively smooth or for those who want to prevent their skin from drying out.
$5.28
Rosette's Rosette Gommage Moist is a moisturizing peeling gel. It's formulated with 3 types of AHAs, earning it an above-average score in the ingredients test.
In our exfoliation test, we found that on average it would remove about 0 to 10% of dead skin, but some testers saw up to a 30% removal.
This product was less exfoliating than Rosette's standard exfoliator. Still, the feel of the two products were nearly identical, so this may be better for those who want a product that's milder in exfoliation.
$6.82
Doushisha's Platinum Label Hatomugi Peeling Gel is free of fragrances, pigment, and alcohol.
Our testers liked how it didn't make their skin feel dry even after rinsing it off, with many commenting that it made their skin feel silky smooth. However, even though it felt great after washing it off, it was lacking in any exfoliating ingredients, bringing down its overall score.
However, it surprisingly removed 50 to 70% of old skin. Some of our testers commented that it makes large exfoliating clumps, so we think that those clumps helped remove old skin.
$24.42
Cure's Natural Aqua Gel is an exfoliant that's made 90% of water, and is a product that's making waves with influencers.
While we couldn't find any exfoliating ingredients in our ingredients test, we did find that it created a lot of gel balls and removed 20 to 40% of our testers' old skin.
While its smooth finish was popular among our testers, there were a few that commented that its watery texture made it quick to evaporate, forcing them to quickly exfoliate their skin.
This exfoliant comes in a standard pump bottle with plenty to go around at 250g, and it can be used not just on the face but the entire body.
$53.95
Mebius Pharmaceutical's Simius Peeling Gel is formulated with 11 different plant-based moisturizing ingredients.
Our testers commented that it made their skin feel a lot smoother than other exfoliants, as well as commented on how it has a thicker texture that prevents it from spilling. This product has the ideal texture for an exfoliating gel.
In our exfoliation test, some of our testers had up to 50% dead skin removed, meaning this product is ideal in smoothing out rough skin.
However, with skin that doesn't have that much dead skin on the surface, this actually increased the amount of dead skin, so it's important to determine whether or not your skin needs exfoliating.
This product is formulated with ethanol, so those with sensitive skin should take care.
$39.99
FANCL's Skin Renewal Pack is an exfoliating gel that is used similar to a face mask, where it's washed off after some time.
One great feature of this exfoliator is that it's packed with moisturizing ingredients and that there's no friction involved, so it's gentle on the skin. Our testers were overjoyed at how their skin felt after rinsing it off, earning this product a higher-than-average score in the feel test.
While it didn't have any particularly great exfoliating ingredients, it is formulated with lactobacillus and fermented pear juice, enabling it to remove roughly up to 10% of our tester's dead skin.
We found that the gel tended to clump around the tip and cap of the tube, requiring regular cleaning. However, we felt that this compact exfoliator is great for taking on trips for on-the-go skincare.
We gathered 10 of the most popular Japanese exfoliators available on e-commerce sites in Japan, such as Amazon, Rakuten, Yahoo! Shopping, and @cosme shopping and tested them all to find the best Japanese exfoliating gel.
We tested each exfoliating gel for the following:
First, we used a tape-style corneum checker to test how exfoliating each peeling gel was.
We first gathered skin cells from skin before using the exfoliating gel. We then had our Japanese testers use each product at the recommended frequency for a week and compared the results.
Products that were able to remove enough dead skin were given a score ranging from 3 to 5, while products that struggled to remove enough were given a score ranging from 1 to 2.
Even if products list exfoliating ingredients in their ingredients chart, it may be the case that they're only formulated with such a small amount that they actually don't have any effect on the skin. The purpose of this test was to find out if the exfoliating gels actually remove dead skin.
Next, we asked our expert, cosmetics consultant Emiko Akahoshi, check each product for their ingredients.
We asked her to check the ingredients based on the following:
When examining the ingredients, we asked Emiko to place a 70% emphasis on the exfoliating ingredients and a 30% emphasis on how gentle they are.
Some products that we tested are classified as quasi-drugs, which is a unique Japanese classification of products that sits in between cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. Manufacturers are not obligated by law to label all their ingredients for quasi-drugs, so Emiko only evaluated those products based on what was written on the label.
The feel of an exfoliating gel is another important aspect to consider. If you're going to exfoliate your skin, you'll want something that makes your skin feel smooth without drying it out.
For this test, we gathered two Japanese testers per product and had them rate each product based on the following aspects:
Products that had a good feel were given a score ranging from 3 to 5, while products that were difficult or unpleasant to use were given a score ranging from 1 to 2.
Most Japanese exfoliating gels work like this: after washing your face, apply the exfoliating gel on your skin and massage it in for about 10 to 30 seconds. Once you see little squishy and clumpy balls form and fall off, you rinse it off with cold or warm water.
There are some products that can exfoliate the skin without any friction. All you need to do is apply it to the skin and wait, similar to a face mask. Make sure to read the instructions or look for reviews online before you buy a new exfoliating gel.
There are also three things to keep in mind when using a Japanese exfoliating gel:
If the product doesn't list how frequent it should be use, it's best to just use it only once a week.
Those with extremely sensitive skin should not use exfoliating gels. By nature, exfoliating gels can be more irritating on the skin in comparison to regular skincare products, and are best for those with normal or tough skin.
If your skin occasionally gets irritated by your skincare products, it's best to reduce your frequency of skin exfoliation and monitor the condition of your skin.
Regardless of your skin type, whenever using a new product, it's best to conduct a patch test on the inside of your arm, such as near your bicep.
Exfoliating gels can irritate the skin, and should not be used on acne. While there are some who use Japanese exfoliating gels to remove acne or minimize the appearance of acne scars, this can actually worsen your condition.
Moreover, cosmetic products aren't formulated with effective ingredients that can treat acne scars. Quasi-drugs that are formulated with brightening ingredients can only help prevent blemishes, so they're best for suppressing melanin production.
Now that you've gotten a Japanese exfoliating gel, check out these other Japanese skincare products. Remember that many exfoliating gels are to be used after washing your face. Also, don't forget to moisturize after exfoliating!
When you purchase products mentioned in the article, part of the sales may be returned to mybest.
The descriptions of each product is referenced from the content available from the manufacturer, e-commerce sites etc.
Apps
Business apps, Cooking apps, Dating appsHome goods
Bath supplies, Ceremonial occasion supplies, Cleaning suppliesHome electronics
Air conditioners and coolers, AV accessories, Blenders and food processorsPC
Computer supplies, Desktop computers, Drawing TabletsCamera
Camera bags and backpacks, Camera supplies, Digital single lens camerasBeauty
Blushes, Bronzers, CleansersHealth
Body care products, Health accessories, Health foods and supplementsFood and drinks
Alcohol, Breads and jams, Cocktails and ready-to-drink alcoholic beveragesKitchen
Coffee and tea products, Cooking utensils, CupsFashion
Footwear products, Men's shoes, SandalsShoes
Accessories
Wristwatches, Accessories and jewelry, Umbrellas and parasolsKids and baby
Baby carriers, Baby food, Baby formulaInterior
Beds, Beds and bedding, ChairsHobbies
Aromatherapy products, Art supplies, Arts and collectiblesOutdoor
Barbecue grills and fire pits, Camping beds and cots, Camping gearHome, garden, and tools
Agricultural materials and gardening supplies, Exterior and garden furniture, Materials and repairing agentsSports and fitness
Sports shoes, Surfing supplies, Badminton suppliesPets
Bird and small animal supplies, Cat supplies, Dog suppliesMedia
Books and magazines, CD, Children's books, picture books and illustrated encyclopediasGames
Gaming accessories, Nintendo Switch games, PC gamesAutomotive
Car accessories, Car navigation systemsGifts
Christmas gifts, Father's Day gifts, Gifts for childrenHousing equipment and renovation
Baths and bathrooms, House building materials, KitchensMobile devices
Mobile phone and smartphone accessories, Wearable devices and smart watchesMobile data
Investment and asset management
Credit cards and loans
Insurance
Music
Others