• 5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed) 1
  • 5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed) 2
  • 5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed) 3
  • 5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed) 4
  • 5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed) 5

5 Best Natural Pacifiers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)

Looking for a safe and soothing binky for your baby without dangerous substances like phthalates and PVC? Natural pacifiers are the way to go, and many parents are seeing their benefits. 


We've done our research and compiled a list of the best natural pacifiers, such as Natursutten's pacifier made seamlessly with natural rubber. There are five more parent and baby-approved pacifiers to choose from, plus a buying guide to get you started on the path of no-plastic baby soothers. 

Experts featured in this article

Dr. Regina Hardin
  • Last updated: 05-06-2022
Table of Contents

In Collaboration With Board-Certified Pediatrician Dr. Regina Hardin

In Collaboration With Board-Certified Pediatrician Dr. Regina Hardin

Dr. Regina Hardin is a pediatrician and the founder of MyKidzMD Pediatrics. She enjoys spending her day caring for newborns and helping parents handle their most common pediatric concerns. You can learn more about Dr. Hardin's work on her Instagram page @mykidz_pediatrics or at her website listed above!


When it comes to her career, Dr. Hardin says:

"Parents are often afraid of routine newborn care for fear of hurting the baby or possibly doing something wrong. My mission is to empower parents with education and by giving them the tools to keep children healthy, happy, and thriving."

Why Get a Natural Pacifier?

Why Get a Natural Pacifier?

The main advantage of getting a natural pacifier is the lack of potentially harmful chemicals and components such as phthalates, parabens, and PVC (polyvinyl chloride).


They're also produced in more eco-friendly ways using sustainable resources. An environmentally-friendly option can go a long way, given a pacifier's short life span. Experts advise replacing pacifiers every two months. Since you'll replace it anyway, one that won't have as much impact on the environment could help!

Dr. Regina Hardin
Pediatrician
Dr. Regina Hardin

Other advantages include them being softer and more like the feel of a breast


Natural rubber is not only used in pacifiers but also in medical devices, gloves used in doctor's offices, balloons, and many toys. Although the risk is not zero, natural rubber pacifiers are less allergenic and don't have any artificial colorants. Biodegradability is a definite plus!

5 Best Natural Pacifiers

Here we have some of the best natural pacifiers. They all have a nipple made from sustainable, natural rubber. You can find round or orthodontic and one- or two-piece versions in the list. 


*Please note that these products were chosen after extensive research by mybest writers. The choices are not necessarily affiliated with or recommended by Dr. Regina Hardin.

1

EcopiggyEcopacifier

$10.99

DesignOne piece
TypeRound
Age group6+ mos.
2

Sophie La GirafeErgonomic Natural Rubber Pacifier

$15.98

DesignOne piece
TypeOrthodontic
Age group0-6, 6-18 mos.
3

HeveaNatural Rubber Pacifier

$9.99

DesignOne piece
TypeRound or orthodontic
Age group0-3, 3-36 mos.
4

NatursuttenButterfly Pacifier

2 pack

$21.00

DesignOne piece
TypeRounded or orthodontic
Age group0-6, 6-12, 12+ mos.
5

BibsBaby Pacifier

2 pack

$15.99

DesignTwo piece
TypeRound
Age group0-6, 6-18, 18-36 mos.

Compare the Best Natural Pacifiers

Image
1
Ecopiggy Ecopacifier 1

Ecopiggy

2
Sophie La Girafe Ergonomic Natural Rubber Pacifier 1

Sophie La Girafe

3
Hevea Natural Rubber Pacifier 1

Hevea

4
Natursutten Butterfly Pacifier 1

Natursutten

5
Bibs Baby Pacifier 1

Bibs

Name

Ecopacifier

Ergonomic Natural Rubber Pacifier

Natural Rubber Pacifier

Butterfly Pacifier

Baby Pacifier

Features

Sustainably-Sourced Natural Rubber Binky

Eco-Friendly Pacifier With an Ergonomic Design

A Pacifier for Easy Transitioning

Natural Rubber Pacifier With a Specially-Designed Shield

Pacifiers With Natural Rubber Nipples Offered in Different Colors

Price$10.99$15.98$9.99$21.00$15.99
DesignOne pieceOne pieceOne pieceOne pieceTwo piece
TypeRoundOrthodonticRound or orthodonticRounded or orthodonticRound
Age group6+ mos.0-6, 6-18 mos.0-3, 3-36 mos.0-6, 6-12, 12+ mos.0-6, 6-18, 18-36 mos.
Link

How to Choose a Natural Pacifier - Buying Guide

If you're new to the idea of using a natural pacifier for your baby, the following buying guide should help explain why this is a parent-approved alternative.

Be Aware That Rubber Comes From Latex

Be Aware That Rubber Comes From Latex

Natural pacifiers are made from rubber. Rubber trees are an eco-friendly and sustainable resource because they can be tapped up to 35 years for material while serving as a habitat for wildlife. In addition, rubber pacifiers are soft, and it has been found that babies like the feel of this material.

 
However, the rubber is made from latex, which is the sap-like component of rubber trees. Therefore, if your child is allergic to latex, this material should be avoided.

Be Aware That Rubber Comes From Latex

Some natural rubber pacifiers have had the latex proteins that trigger allergies removed during production. Still, experts advise those with diagnosed latex allergies to proceed with caution when choosing such "latex-free" products.


The FDA has recommended that manufacturers stop using the term since it is too vague to be helpful. There is no accurate test to determine if a natural rubber has zero allergy-causing latex proteins. In addition, the production or packaging process could still result in contamination.


Latex exposure over time is a factor in the development of an allergy to it, so if you are concerned about this, it's best to avoid natural rubber pacifiers altogether.

Dr. Regina Hardin
Pediatrician
Dr. Regina Hardin

What might an allergy to latex look like? Symptoms could include itching, redness, hives, rash, runny nose, cough, wheezing, swelling, or trouble breathing. The reaction or reactions can be mild to severe


Parents, siblings, or close family members who have latex or food allergies should first discuss the use of natural rubber pacifiers with the pediatrician.

Pick Between an Orthodontic and a Round Pacifier

Pick Between an Orthodontic and a Round Pacifier

Pacifiers have three key parts: the nipple, which should be soft and comfortable for the baby to suckle on; the shield, to stop the nipple from becoming a choking hazard; and the ring, to make it easy to remove and hold the pacifier.


From there, you have two main designs or pacifier shapes: orthodontic and round pacifiers. Orthodontic pacifiers have a flat nipple on the bottom side and a rounded area at the top. The design complements the baby’s flat tongue surface and curved roof area of the mouth.


Meanwhile, round pacifiers have nipples that are round throughout, much like a baby bottle nipple, and it mimics a female’s nipple. You might need to mix and match a particular nipple type to your baby’s preference, so we recommend trying out different shapes until you find one that sticks.

Dr. Regina Hardin
Pediatrician
Dr. Regina Hardin

Orthodontic pacifiers help lessen the pressure on the baby's gums and developing teeth, which helps with issues like malalignment, including overbite and underbite. 


However, whether the choice is orthodontic or traditional round shape, the length of use can play a factor, as both types can be problematic if used for long periods of time.

Check the Size Based on Age

Check the Size Based on Age

Pacifiers are often created in different sizes depending on a baby’s age or developmental stage. The pacifier size is a crucial consideration to ensure that it isn’t too big or too small for their mouth, both for optimal soothing and to minimize choking risks.

 
You can find pacifiers for made for babies from newborn to three or six months old and older. We recommend checking the product dimensions carefully as manufacturers don’t follow a standard regarding the sizing of pacifiers and the nipples. 

Double-Check the Design for Safety

Double-Check the Design for Safety

Natural pacifiers often feature a seamless design, wherein the rubber is molded out of one piece with a shield that is at least an inch and a half wide so that your baby can’t put the entire piece into their mouth. A multi-piece pacifier should be securely fastened without the risk of the nipple accidentally dislodging and becoming a choking hazard.

 
We recommend pacifiers with holes in the shield to allow for air circulation. A baby’s saliva can quickly accumulate behind the shield, and the ventilation helps reduce rashes or irritation.


We advise periodically cleaning it when needed with soap and warm water to prevent dirt and bacteria buildup. Some are dishwasher-safe, so give the product description a look-through regarding this.

Decide if Your Baby Needs a Pacifier

Decide if Your Baby Needs a Pacifier

You might be wondering if babies need a pacifier at all, as some parents swear by it while others consider it detrimental to a child’s development.


Pacifiers were created to calm and soothe babies through the sucking motion mimicking breast or bottle feeding. Some studies have shown that pacifiers may help reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), which happens during deep sleep. Pacifiers also mean babies don’t suck their fingers or items they come into contact with.


On the downside, pacifiers have been found to increase the risk of dental problems. There is also the chance of the child losing interest in breastfeeding after being too accustomed to a pacifier. Therefore, going the pacifier route depends solely on the parent and what they deem fit for their child.

Dr. Regina Hardin
Pediatrician
Dr. Regina Hardin

Other reasons to consider using a pacifier might include easing ear discomfort caused by cabin pressure changes when flying on an airplane, helping to soothe your baby through painful procedures, easing the process of falling asleep and settling down for your baby. Of note, not all babies will need or accept a pacifier.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you have questions about caring for your baby's natural pacifier, check out Dr. Regina's input below!

What's the best way to clean a natural pacifier?

Dr. Hardin says, "The best way to clean a natural rubber pacifier and to ensure adequate shelf life is to boil it initially for five minutes when you receive it. Allow it to cool down and dry on a clean towel. 


For subsequent cleanings, using warm water and baby-safe dish soap is sufficient. Remember to replace your baby's pacifier every six to eight weeks."

A Pediatrician's Favorite Natural Pacifier

In addition to her advice in our buying Guide, Dr. Hardin was also kind enough to recommend her favorite natural pacifier. 

NatursuttenOriginal Natural Rubber Pacifier

$12.00

DesignOne piece
TypeRound or orthodontic
Age group06, 6-12, 12+ mos.

Try These Baby Essentials Parents Love

You might be interested in adding these must-have items for your nursery to make parenting and child-rearing more convenient, efficient, hygienic, and safe for your baby. 

Author: Hana Otsuka


  • Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for more mybest recommendations! For questions or comments, leave us feedback via a Google Form on our Contact Us page.

Related Articles

  • 10 Best Baby Strollers in 2022 (Graco, Kolcraft, and More)
    10 Best Baby Strollers in 2022 (Graco, Kolcraft, and More)
    No matter if you're going to a park or a shopping mall, you probably need a baby stroller to help make your on-the-go life with your baby much easier. Nevertheless, due to the plethora of baby strollers coming from well-known brands such as Summer Infant, Baby Trend, or Kolcraft, choosing a suitable product that can make your child feel comfortable and is easy to use can be difficult.Understanding that struggle, we looked through many products on the Internet and compiled a list of the 10 best baby strollers to help you figure out which product to purchase. Summer Infant's Summer 3Dlite Convenience Stroller is one of our favorites, as it's durable and has many safety and comfort features. We also included a buying guide to help you find out which is the best for your baby.
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Organic Milk Baby Formulas in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Organic Milk Baby Formulas in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    If you can't breast-feed or just decide not to, using milk-based baby formula is important to supply your baby with enough nutrients. However, not all baby formulas contain high-quality ingredients that are safe for your baby. By choosing an organic product, you avoid many harmful chemicals and additives in your baby's diet. So if you want to find out more about which organic milk baby formulas would be safe for your baby, keep scrolling. Our top 10 organic milk baby formulas and buying guide will give you some hints in choosing the most suitable product for your baby! 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Reusable Food Pouches in 2022
    10 Best Reusable Food Pouches in 2022
    Have you been on a trip and had a hard time feeding your little one? Don't worry, reusable food pouches are the perfect solution for on-the-go situations! Even without adults' help, babies can squeeze and eat food easily from these little pouches. With so many options out there, we've done the work for you to provide our Top 10 favorites. After thorough research, WeeSprout's Nature's Little Squeeze Pouches took the top spot. They come in a variety of different sizes and are designed with rounded corners for easy cleaning. Curious to know what other products made the cut in our top 10 list? Keep reading! We also compiled a buying guide to give you some tips for choosing the right one. 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Makeup Kits for Kids in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Makeup Kits for Kids in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    There comes a time when our little one becomes interested in the products that we apply on our faces. Children mimic by nature, and if they spot us applying makeup frequently, this only piques their interest! However, not all of the cosmetics we use are safe for their skin. Plus, we want to encourage them to see makeup as something that's fun - not a necessity!Thus, makeup kits for kids were born. These are guaranteed to be safe for hours of fun! Make It Up's Glamour Girl Pretend Play Makeup Set, for example, is made with safe materials and looks so realistic that it could fool even adults. If you're looking at other makeup kit options, there's a buying below to help you choose the best makeup kit for your aspiring artist. 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Walkie Talkies for Kids in 2022 (Motorola, Obuby, and More)
    10 Best Walkie Talkies for Kids in 2022 (Motorola, Obuby, and More)
    Maybe you have poor reception or your little ones are not yet ready for a cellphone. That's where walkie talkies can come in handy! Walkie talkies are handheld, portable two-way radio devices that allow communication on specific channel frequencies, usually within a range of five miles or lower. They may also include features like a built-in flashlight, radio, headset jack, and more.With so many options to choose from, we've researched and put together 10 walkie talkies for kids that Amazon reviewers love. Our favorite pick is the T100 Talkabout Radio from Motorola since they're from a reliable brand, have an above-average range, and is great for families. For more of our favorites, please read on! Also, take a look at our buying guide for some tips on how to choose the right set of walkie talkies for your kids.
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Kids Gardening Tools in 2022 (Melissa & Doug, Clever Kid Toys, and More)
    10 Best Kids Gardening Tools in 2022 (Melissa & Doug, Clever Kid Toys, and More)
    In need of ways to engage your child through a multi-beneficial activity? Gardening is one idea worth a try. Make their experience more fun through gardening tools catered for kids. We've got you covered with some of the best, parent-approved tools to consider! After much deliberation, Melissa & Doug's Giddy Buggy Watering Can has taken the top spot for its function and style. There are nine more tools, including sets, you can look through, plus a buying guide to start you off on your gardening tools shopping needs. 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Baby Nail Trimmers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Baby Nail Trimmers in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    When it's time to trim your baby's nails, you need a pair of nail trimmers that are designed just for babies. These tools are small enough to make it easy to maneuver them around your baby's tiny fingers. They're also equipped with safety features that make them safe to use even on the most sensitive and delicate nails.However, since there are a lot of different baby nail trimmers out there, it can be a bit too much to have to pick just one. Well, mybest has got that part covered! We came up with a top 10 list of the best baby nail trimmers for you. Topping this list is Royal Angels' 20-in-1 baby nail clipper set, which is electrical and comes with attachments for people of all ages. Check out the rest of the items we picked out and give our buyer's guide a read while you're at it to learn what to look for in a pair of baby nail trimmers.
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Snorkel Masks for Kids in 2022 (Cressi, Promate, and More)
    10 Best Snorkel Masks for Kids in 2022 (Cressi, Promate, and More)
    Whether your kids are casual surface snorkelers or if they love to dive deep, you always need the proper gear to ensure their safety as they explore the underwater world. There is the danger of having an ill-fitting mask that might result in an uncomfortable snorkeling experience. In snorkeling, your kids' eyes and nose must be protected. The material of the mask and the type of snorkeling tube matters to ensure that your kids will be protected while they have fun.To make things easier, we've created a list of 10 of the best kid's snorkel masks out there. Begin with our first choice, Cressi's Snorkeling Kit for Kids. This snorkeling mask has buckles that make it easy to adjust for kids. Along with nine other great options, we also have included a buying guide to help you know what to keep in mind when buying a snorkeling mask. Read on!
    Kids and baby
  • 7 Best Wooden Teethers in 2022 (Loulou Lollipop, Maple Landmark, and More)
    7 Best Wooden Teethers in 2022 (Loulou Lollipop, Maple Landmark, and More)
    Is your child chewing his way through teethers, making you believe that there's nothing out there that can withstand those powerful gums? Perhaps it's time to give wooden teethers a try. They're durable and provide the right hardness for teething babies. That's why we looked for the best ones out there. For starters, take a look at Promise Babe's teething rings which are customizable, versatile, and made from 100 percent beech wood. We've got six more options for you to consider, plus a buying guide to assist you in choosing the best wooden teether for your little one. 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Dinosaur Toys in 2022 (LEGO, Wild Republic, and More)
    10 Best Dinosaur Toys in 2022 (LEGO, Wild Republic, and More)
    Are you looking for the ideal toy for a big dinosaur fan? Children have long been obsessed with these prehistoric creatures, so it's no surprise that there are so many dinosaur toys available. Whether you're looking for something educational, buildable, or just plain fun, there is a dinosaur toy for everyone.That's why we’ve done the research for you and picked the best dinosaur toys around. We chose the Dinosaur Toy Painting Kit by Baodlon as our favorite due to the contents of the kit, the quality of the dinosaurs, and the creativity it can unleash. We’ve also put together a top 10 list for you to consider and created a handy buying guide to help you make your choice!
    Kids and baby
  • Popular Articles

  • 10 Best Lactose-Free and Lactose-Reduced Baby Formulas in 2022 (Similac, Baby's Only Organic, and More)
    10 Best Lactose-Free and Lactose-Reduced Baby Formulas in 2022 (Similac, Baby's Only Organic, and More)
    Babies with lactose intolerance definitely have it hard. If they can't consume breastmilk and conventional formulas are tough to digest, you should consider a suitable lactose-free product in order to provide your baby the nutrients they need. There are various lactose-free options ranging from soy-based to hypoallergenic. But how can you choose the best one?That's where we come in. We researched and compiled a list of our top 10 favorite lactose-free and lactose-reduced baby formulas on the market. Along with our favorite, Enfamil's Nutramigen formula, we've got nine other options. We also have a buying guide full of tips on how to find the best one on your own!
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Health Drinks for Children in 2022 (PediaSure, Honest Kids, and More)
    10 Best Health Drinks for Children in 2022 (PediaSure, Honest Kids, and More)
    Keeping your kids healthy is a top concern, and yet with your busy schedule, you might not have the time to research what health drinks can best get them through the day. You have an overwhelming amount of options, all claiming to be the best, so it can be a challenge finding out exactly which health drink best meets your child’s needs.In this article, we are going to teach you how to select the best health drink for the kids in your life, based on factors such as what you want the drink to be used to do and included nutrients. Our personal favorite drink was Kids Protein Nutritional Shake since it's packed with tons of protein, vitamins, and minerals and comes in a convenient package. Read on to discover other most popular health drinks for children on the market this year!
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Makeup Kits for Kids in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Makeup Kits for Kids in 2022 (Pediatrician-Reviewed)
    There comes a time when our little one becomes interested in the products that we apply on our faces. Children mimic by nature, and if they spot us applying makeup frequently, this only piques their interest! However, not all of the cosmetics we use are safe for their skin. Plus, we want to encourage them to see makeup as something that's fun - not a necessity!Thus, makeup kits for kids were born. These are guaranteed to be safe for hours of fun! Make It Up's Glamour Girl Pretend Play Makeup Set, for example, is made with safe materials and looks so realistic that it could fool even adults. If you're looking at other makeup kit options, there's a buying below to help you choose the best makeup kit for your aspiring artist. 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Sand and Water Tables in 2022 (Little Tikes, Step2, and More)
    10 Best Sand and Water Tables in 2022 (Little Tikes, Step2, and More)
    A sand and water table is a great activity to keep your kids entertained in warmer weather. The grainy texture of the sand, the cool water, and the fun accessories that come with the play table are bound to keep your child occupied. That's why we did the research to find the best sand and water tables out there and summarized them into a top 10 listTopping it is Little Tike's Spiralin’ Seas Waterpark Play Table, which comes with fun contraptions and water squirters. Check out the rest of the products on our curated list and make sure to head over to the buying guide section to read up on what to look out for!
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Scissors for Kids in 2022 (Fiskars, Westcott, and More)
    10 Best Scissors for Kids in 2022 (Fiskars, Westcott, and More)
    Kids love art. Coloring, drawing, gluing, painting, and cutting. Scissor crafts aren't just a creative outlet for children, but they also serve as an activity that engages their fine motor skills, thanks to the finger movements needed to get a pair of scissors to open and close. However, finding the right pair of scissors for your little one can be quite difficult because of the safety concerns as well as the number of scissors to choose from. Well, we at mybest don't want you stressing out. So, we looked far and wide and came up with a curated top 10 list for you of the best scissors for kids out there! At the top of our list is Livingo's Blunt Tip Kids' Craft Scissors, which are super safe and come with cool sheaths. Check out our buyer's guide while you're at it to learn what to consider when picking out a pair of scissors for your little one. 
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Water Mats for Babies in 2022 (TIKTOK, VATOS, and More)
    10 Best Water Mats for Babies in 2022 (TIKTOK, VATOS, and More)
    Are you looking for a fun way to diversify your baby’s tummy time routine? Do you want to incorporate water play, but don’t want to deal with the mess that comes with it? Then a water mat may be exactly what you and your infant need! We have assembled a versatile list of the very best mats available for introducing little minds to big worlds while supporting healthy development in the process.Topping this impressive list is an oversized shark-themed mat from TIKTOK that entices the eye while stoking the imagination! We hope the information and options provided in this guide will help you and your little fish as you both dive into the wonderful world of water play!
    Kids and baby
  • 10 Best Kid's Craft Kits in 2022 (Crayola, Disney, and More)
    10 Best Kid's Craft Kits in 2022 (Crayola, Disney, and More)
    Craft kits are great tools to promote creativity and self-expression in children. The activity choices are also endless, ranging from painting to building, to cutting paper. However, the plethora of options also makes it hard to choose a suitable craft kit for your child. You probably need to consider a lot of factors including the materials of the craft kit and the interests of your child. Therefore, to help you figure out which craft kit to purchase, we've combed through various reviews on Amazon and compiled a list of the top 10 craft kits recommended by users. We also created a buying guide at the end to give you some more tips in choosing the most suitable kit for your child! 
    Kids and baby
  • Popular Expert Picks

    Search by Category