• Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts in 2020 (Dr. Scholl's, Tread Labs, and More) 1
  • Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts in 2020 (Dr. Scholl's, Tread Labs, and More) 2
  • Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts in 2020 (Dr. Scholl's, Tread Labs, and More) 3
  • Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts in 2020 (Dr. Scholl's, Tread Labs, and More) 4
  • Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts in 2020 (Dr. Scholl's, Tread Labs, and More) 5

Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts in 2020 (Dr. Scholl's, Tread Labs, and More)

Have you ever felt intense pain in your foot that has prevented you from moving? Whether it's from your heels, uncomfortable shoes, or a sports injury, foot pain is very challenging to set aside. Fortunately, we have shoe inserts that provide cushioning and support for your feet!


Take Tread Labs' Pace Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Soles, for example. They're designed specifically to address common and very painful foot conditions. We've picked out nine other shoe inserts and insoles to help with your foot troubles in our top 10 list. There is also a buying guide included to help you find the best inserts for your shoes!

  • Last updated: 12-16-2020
  • 77 views
Table of Contents

Top 10 Best Shoe Inserts

The list below contains bestselling shoe inserts and insoles from Amazon and Walmart. You can find an insert for each arch type, foot area, foot condition, and material to best suit your needs.

1

WalkizeMetatarsal Pads

$13.97

TypeOTC
Insert/insole formMetatarsal
MaterialGel and cloth
HighlightsNon-slip, one size fits most
Arch type-
2

PowerstepFull Length Orthotic Shoe Insoles

$32.70

TypeOrthotic
Insert/insole formFull-length
MaterialEVA foam
Arch typeNeutral, low, high
HighlightsDeep heel cup, anti-microbial
3

Tread LabsPace Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Insoles

$65.00

TypeOrthotic
Insert/insole formFull-length
MaterialFoam
Arch typeNeutral, medium, high, extra high
HighlightsFour arch heights, replaceable top layer
4

Dr. Scholl'sMassaging Gel Advanced Insoles

$10.88

TypeOrthotic
Insert/insole formFull-length
MaterialGel and foam
Arch typeNeutral, low
HighlightsTrimmable, massaging design, latex-free
5

FitFeetOrthotic Inserts 3/4 Length

$20.89

TypeOrthotic
Insert/insole form2/3 or 3/4
MaterialEVA polymer foam
Arch typeHigh, very high
HighlightsDeep heel cup, anti-skid, anti-microbial, sweat-wicking
6

Dr. FootHeight Increase Insoles

$12.99

TypeOTC
Insert/insole formHeel lift
MaterialGet and cloth
Arch type-
HighlightsHeight increase, shock absorption, depressurizing
7

SpencoPolysorb Cross Trainer Athletic Cushioning Arch Support Shoe Insoles

$12.93

TypeOTC
Insert/insole formFull-length
MaterialFoam and nylon
Arch typeNeutral
HighlightsAnti-microbial, odor-control
8

KidSoleSport Traction Shock Absorbing Lightweight Gel Heel Cups

$19.99

TypeOTC
Insert/insole formHeel cups
MaterialGel
Arch typeNeutral, high
HighlightsTraction layer for better grip
9

Mars WellnessAdjustable Orthopedic Heel Lift

$7.20

TypeOrthotic
Insert/insole formHeel lifts
MaterialRubber
HighlightsLayered and adjustable
Arch type-
10

ProtalusPatented Stress Relief Replacement Shoe Inserts

$46.96

TypeOrthotic
Insert/insole formFull-length
MaterialEVA polymer foam
Arch typeNeutral, high
HighlightsTrimmable, moisture-wicking, anti-microbial

Compare the Best Shoe Inserts

Image
1
Walkize Metatarsal Pads 1

Walkize

2
Powerstep Full Length Orthotic Shoe Insoles 1

Powerstep

3
Tread Labs Pace Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Insoles 1

Tread Labs

4
Dr. Scholl's Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles 1

Dr. Scholl's

5
FitFeet Orthotic Inserts 3/4 Length 1

FitFeet

6
Dr. Foot Height Increase Insoles 1

Dr. Foot

7
Spenco Polysorb Cross Trainer Athletic Cushioning Arch Support Shoe Insoles 1

Spenco

8
KidSole Sport Traction Shock Absorbing Lightweight Gel Heel Cups 1

KidSole

9
Mars Wellness Adjustable Orthopedic Heel Lift 1

Mars Wellness

10
Protalus Patented Stress Relief Replacement Shoe Inserts 1

Protalus

Name

Metatarsal Pads

Full Length Orthotic Shoe Insoles

Pace Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Insoles

Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles

Orthotic Inserts 3/4 Length

Height Increase Insoles

Polysorb Cross Trainer Athletic Cushioning Arch Support Shoe Insoles

Sport Traction Shock Absorbing Lightweight Gel Heel Cups

Adjustable Orthopedic Heel Lift

Patented Stress Relief Replacement Shoe Inserts

Features

Instant Metatarsal Relief Shoe Inserts

A Low-Profile, High-Support Insole

Podiatrist-Recommended Pain Relief Insoles

Insoles With Added Massage Feature

2/3 Shoe Inserts for Pain Relief

A Shock-Absorbing Heel Support

Athletic Insoles With a Crash Pad

Heel Cups for Kids With Sensitive Soles

An Adjustable Heel Lift

A Multi-Layer Insole For Increased Support

Price$13.97$32.70$65.00$10.88$20.89$12.99$12.93$19.99$7.20$46.96
TypeOTCOrthoticOrthoticOrthoticOrthoticOTCOTCOTCOrthoticOrthotic
Insert/insole formMetatarsalFull-lengthFull-lengthFull-length 2/3 or 3/4Heel liftFull-lengthHeel cupsHeel liftsFull-length
MaterialGel and clothEVA foamFoamGel and foamEVA polymer foamGet and clothFoam and nylonGelRubberEVA polymer foam
Arch typeNon-slip, one size fits mostNeutral, low, highNeutral, medium, high, extra highNeutral, lowHigh, very high-NeutralNeutral, highLayered and adjustableNeutral, high
Highlights-Deep heel cup, anti-microbialFour arch heights, replaceable top layerTrimmable, massaging design, latex-freeDeep heel cup, anti-skid, anti-microbial, sweat-wickingHeight increase, shock absorption, depressurizingAnti-microbial, odor-controlTraction layer for better grip-Trimmable, moisture-wicking, anti-microbial
Link

How to Choose a Shoe Insert - Buying Guide

To help you find the best one for you, here is a buying guide that explains shoe inserts in detail. We explain how to choose a shoe insert according to your needs.

Opt for Over-the-Counter Inserts or Consults With Your Doctor

First, we must differentiate among the different kinds of inserts and insoles and get acquainted with their purpose. You can consider "over-the-counter shoe inserts", which are readily available without a prescription.

Partial Shoe Inserts for Specific Issues

Partial Shoe Inserts for Specific Issues

Partial shoe inserts target a specific area of the foot that typically needs support or pain relief. You can consider heel cups to address heel pain through cushioning and shock absorption. You can also find heel lifts that help relieve calf and ankle pain by raising the heel to remove strain on this area.


Metatarsal pads, on the other hand, are placed on the front of the shoe. These are recommended for people who walk in heels a lot and put pressure on the ball of the foot or those with conditions like Morton’s neuroma, a painful condition affecting the ball of the foot.

Partial Shoe Inserts for Specific Issues

Another type is a two-thirds shoe insert that runs from the heel to just before the balls of the feet. These are designed for those who don’t feel pain or don’t require extra support for strenuous activities like a marathon but are simply looking for added comfort throughout the day.


The shape and size of two-thirds - also known as three-quarters - shoe inserts are perfect for flat, casual, or dress footwear. A two-thirds insert is also often used on shoes that do not have removable inserts. They’re thin and can be placed inside your shoes.

Full-Length Insoles to Support the Entire Foot

Full-Length Insoles to Support the Entire Foot

Full-length insoles are purchased according to the size of your shoe and added for extra comfort, arch support, and cushioning.


You'll often need to remove the existing insole from the shoe before placing the new one, so this is something to keep in mind, especially if you like your existing soles for their comfort. A workaround is adding the inserts on top, but you will be limited to very thin or flat full-sized insoles as a bulky one can jeopardize the shoe's overall fit.

Full-Length Insoles to Support the Entire Foot

Those with flat feet are often prescribed full-length insoles with arch to push for the foot's natural form or biomechanics. Arches are essential for moving efficiently, minimizing shock, and improving balance.


Rigid flat feet that are flat when standing or sitting are often paired with low arch insoles. Meanwhile, flexible flat feet, or arches that appear when sitting, require medium arch insoles.

Go for Custom Orthotics With a Recommendation

Go for Custom Orthotics With a Recommendation

Custom orthotics, or orthopedic insoles, are prescribed by a doctor and constructed specifically for your foot, to give support or address an existing issue. Whether the issue is a diabetic foot ulcer or a foot injury, custom-made inserts can tackle individual problems. They can be 3D-printed, made from scratch, or pre-made.


We recommend going for custom orthotics if you are struggling with existing foot pain or issue. This way, you get the assurance that you are addressing the problem directly and minimizing the chances of using the wrong insert.


There are also orthopedic, orthotic, or podiatrist-recommended inserts available online that address specific foot conditions. While these may be a better option than universal ones, it is best to read through the reviews for confirmation whether the product provided the right support or not.

Anti-Microbial and Trim-to-Fit Features are Important

Anti-Microbial and Trim-to-Fit Features are Important

Much like any product, inserts have features that make them more worthwhile. For example, you can get ones with antimicrobial features to keep the buildup of foot odor to a low. There are extra ingredients or materials used on the insert to limit mold, mildew, yeasts, or algae, which contribute to odor.


Another feature to consider is the option to trim the soles to fit your shoe size correctly. The sizing of inserts can be a hit or miss, especially non-custom ones. They can be too broad or crawl up the sides of the insoles.

Choose from Foam, Gel, Cork or Leather Inserts

Choose from Foam, Gel, Cork or Leather Inserts

The most common materials used for inserts are foam, gel, cork, and leather. Foam has a reputation for being the best for cushioning, support, and pressure relief. Meanwhile, gel is great at shock absorption because it retains its form despite the pressure.


Cork is for optimal support with a bit of cushioning and leather is best for a comfortable feel of the insert as well as adequate cushioning.

Check if You Need Specialized Insoles

Check if You Need Specialized Insoles

There are also other types of inserts that serve a specific or seasonal purpose. For example, warm or wool insoles are great for their insulation properties. This means your feet stay cool during summer and warm during winter. A wool insole is perfect for those who spend a lot of time outdoors or stay at low temperatures beyond typical comfort levels.


You can also find inserts or insoles with heat-moldable properties or memory cushioning to better conform to the curves of your foot. A heat-moldable insole will take form according to your foot shape and stay that way.

Check if You Need Specialized Insoles

Meanwhile, memory foam reverts to its original state. Memory foam is excellent for heavy-duty cushioning because you can rely on the comfort and support for extended periods of time.


Inserts for athletes or sports are another example of a more specialized type. These have a more technical design and cater to a specific sport or activity by using the best material to achieve optimal performance. For example, cyclists require rigid and compact inserts in their footwear, while runners need something more flexible.

Get More Support for Your Feet

Get More Support for Your Feet

Not quite satisfied or relieved from pain? Pamper your feet with these foot-related essentials.

Summary

Feet are not a one-size-fits-all kind of thing. Metatarsal inserts, heel lifts, or full-length insoles - every person has a unique need. Luckily, there are ways to achieve supportive footwear that can keep up with your specific demands. We hope we helped you find some relief!


Author: Hana Otsuka


Related Articles

Popular Articles

  • Top 14 Best Japanese Business Shoes to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 14 Best Japanese Business Shoes to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites (such as @cosme, Amazon, and Yahoo Shopping) for the best men’s business shoes. We then chose the 14 most popular products and tested them for the following:1. Craftsmanship2. Material3. Comfort4. Water-ResistanceWe were looking for shoes that would be easy to walk in, rain or shine. We also considered breathable options for folks who stand all day. We even enlisted the help of a journalist who specializes in men’s fashion to check for quality. What we ended up with was a definitive list of and buying guide about the best Japanese business shoes available online.
    Shoes
    2,069 views
  • Top 10 Best Men's Hiking Sandals in 2020 (TEVA, Crocs, and More)
    Top 10 Best Men's Hiking Sandals in 2020 (TEVA, Crocs, and More)
    If the weather has become hot and humid, and you dread having your feet bound up in those heavy hiking boots of yours, it may be time to consider alternating with a good pair of hiking sandals. Luckily, there are wide selections of hiking sandals available that function just as well or better than your big heavy strapped-up hiking boots, without sacrificing style.The number of hiking sandals available on the market today can be staggering, but we've picked out ten of our favorite pairs to make your hiking experience the best. The TEVA Men’s Hurricane XLT Sandal, in a nutshell, has everything the average hiker will need: support, breathability, and durability. It's also waterproof, lightweight, and easy to throw on and off. Read on for more great choices and a buying guide to help you pick one on your own!
    Shoes
    286 views
  • Top 10 Best Snow Boots in 2020 (Columbia, Kamik, and More)
    Top 10 Best Snow Boots in 2020 (Columbia, Kamik, and More)
    You don’t need to be buried 10 feet deep in snow to appreciate a good pair of snow boots. You have your Northface boots and Columbia boots, your fancy designs and waterproof materials, your heat insulation, and slip prevention. They’re all great, but which pair is best for you?So first, let’s talk about how to choose a good pair of snow boots. We’ll look at popular retail products with an eye out for design and functionality after introducing our favorite UGG boots and the rest of our top 10 picks. May you find a warm companion for those gray, grimy days.
    Shoes
    702 views
  • Top 10 Best Women's Indoor Slippers in 2020 (UGG, Acorn, and More)
    Top 10 Best Women's Indoor Slippers in 2020 (UGG, Acorn, and More)
    Home is a place of comfort, and indoor slippers can help us stay relaxed and cozy. Of course, they keep our feet warm and snug. They also provide protection from hard or dirty surfaces and even provide structural support to keep us healthy and balanced! Plus, keeping your feet warm can have many benefits, like boosting your immune system by keeping your blood circulating.So, we searched for the best indoor slippers available online. The versatile Tasman Slipper from UGG made with warm, durable wool and suede made it to the top of our list! We included the other slippers that stood out to us against the others, so read on to find the pair that's right for you. Be sure to check out our buying guide for plenty of useful information, too.
    Shoes
    124 views
  • Top 9 Best Men's Waterproof Hiking Boots in 2020 (Salomon, Under Armour, and More)
    Top 9 Best Men's Waterproof Hiking Boots in 2020 (Salomon, Under Armour, and More)
    Do you long to spend time in the great outdoors? Is your hiking footwear beginning to fail the test of time? Take a peek at our top ten best men's hiking boots! Life can be an uphill climb, but it's a little easier when you have the right hiking footwear. Whether you're backpacking, day hiking, or camping, a good pair of hiking boots will do you good.Our number one pick for the best men's hiking boot is the Danner Men's Gore-Tex Hiking Boot. It has a speedy lace system to make gearing up a little easier. But, we've included other options for the novice climber, the expert mountaineer, the outdoorsy vegan, and everyone in between. When you're done you can walk on over to our buyer's guide for extra tips and tricks for purchasing the right fit for your foot!
    Shoes
    421 views
  • Top 10 Best Thigh High Boots in 2021 (Stuart Weitzman, Jessica Simpson, and More)
    Top 10 Best Thigh High Boots in 2021 (Stuart Weitzman, Jessica Simpson, and More)
    When it comes to dramatic shoes, thigh high boots are at the top of the list. They make your legs look miles long, adding instant glam, elegance, and sexiness to any outfit. Depending on the style and heel height, they can be work-appropriate or party-ready. And they're surprisingly versatile. They look cool and chic over jeans, casual with leggings, and flirty under a dress or skirt. We've compiled a list of our top 10 best thigh high boots, from flat boots to sky-high stilettos. For a cute basic boot that's easy to mix and match with your wardrobe, we recommend the Tonya Microsuede Heeled Boots from A New Day. The block heel and round toe are classic and chic, while the faux suede material is both work and play-appropriate. Find your new favorite boots in our top 10 list below and don't forget to check out the buying guide for tips on how to choose a pair that suits you!
    Shoes
    162 views
  • Top 10 Best Water Shoes for the Beach in 2020 (Teva, Keen, and More)
    Top 10 Best Water Shoes for the Beach in 2020 (Teva, Keen, and More)
    Are you looking to keep your feet safe while you swim in the ocean or a pool? Or are you concerned about slipping when you step in and out of the water? If so, then water shoes could be a great solution for you! These are waterproof shoes or sandals that are specially designed to protect your feet in these situations. However, there are so many different brands for these shoes that choosing the best ones for you can become a little overwhelming. But fret no more; we're here to help you make the best choice! We did the homework for you and picked out 10 of the best water shoes to wear at the beach. In particular, we loved the Keen Whisper Sandals. They offer protection, traction and they are very light. Keep reading our guide to learn about other great water shoes for you and your family, as well as helpful hints on how to find a great pair on your own!
    Shoes
    322 views
  • Popular Item Lists

    Search by Category