• Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves in 2020 (Ultra Pro, Ryker, and More) 1
  • Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves in 2020 (Ultra Pro, Ryker, and More) 2
  • Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves in 2020 (Ultra Pro, Ryker, and More) 3
  • Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves in 2020 (Ultra Pro, Ryker, and More) 4
  • Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves in 2020 (Ultra Pro, Ryker, and More) 5

Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves in 2020 (Ultra Pro, Ryker, and More)

Trading cards are popular with a wide range of ages and have been for many years. They can be used to play fantasy games, be traded between friends, or collected as beloved memorabilia. Whatever your purpose for collecting trading cards is, you'll need to buy some protective sleeves if you want to keep them in mint condition.


We've looked at the best trading card sleeves available and chose the Diamond Shield cards in matte silver by Arcane Tinman as our favorites. They will protect your cards and are perfect for use in games with friends or even in tournaments. We've also put together a top 10 list for you to consider and created a handy buying guide to help you make your choice!

  • Last updated: 11-25-2020
  • 536 views
Table of Contents

Top 10 Best Trading Card Sleeves

We've searched Amazon to find the best trading card sleeves available. We've picked a variety of sleeves, so no matter what you're looking for, we have some trading card sleeves for you!

1

Arcane TinmanDragon Shield Matte Silver

AT-11008

$10.95

Sleeve typeSoft
Number100
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.
2

Ultra ProToploaders and Clear Sleeves

$29.09

Sleeve typeToploader and soft
Number100 toploaders, 100 soft
Size3 x 4 in.
3

Quiver TimeUltra Transparent Standard Deck Protectors

$17.90

Sleeve typeSoft
Number300
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.
4

Toupeone9-Pocket Sleeves for 3 Ring Binder

$6.99

Sleeve typeSheets
Number30 pages
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.
5

Ultra ProSoft Card Sleeves

$6.50

Sleeve typeSoft
Number100
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.
6

RYKERStandard Size Matte Card Sleeves

$11.97

Sleeve typeSoft
Number150
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.
7

TitanShieldBlack Standard Size Board Game Trading Card Sleeves

$9.99

Sleeve typeSoft
Number150
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.
8

Pro Support Trading Card AccessoriesPerfect Fit Ultra Clear

$19.99

Sleeve typeSoft
Number400
Size2.5 x 3.5 in.
9

BCWTrading Card Toploader Holder

$8.98

Sleeve typeToploader
Number25
Size3 x 4 in.
10

POKONBOYTrading Card Storage Pages

$7.95

Sleeve typeSheets
Number32 pages
Size3.6 x 2.75 in.

Compare the Best Trading Card Sleeves

Image
1
Arcane Tinman Dragon Shield Matte Silver 1

Arcane Tinman

2
Ultra Pro Toploaders and Clear Sleeves 1

Ultra Pro

3
Quiver Time Ultra Transparent Standard Deck Protectors 1

Quiver Time

4
Toupeone 9-Pocket Sleeves for 3 Ring Binder 1

Toupeone

5
Ultra Pro Soft Card Sleeves 1

Ultra Pro

6
RYKER Standard Size Matte Card Sleeves 1

RYKER

7
TitanShield Black Standard Size Board Game Trading Card Sleeves  1

TitanShield

8
Pro Support Trading Card Accessories Perfect Fit Ultra Clear 1

Pro Support Trading Card Accessories

9
BCW Trading Card Toploader Holder 1

BCW

10
POKONBOY Trading Card Storage Pages 1

POKONBOY

Name

Dragon Shield Matte Silver

Toploaders and Clear Sleeves

Ultra Transparent Standard Deck Protectors

9-Pocket Sleeves for 3 Ring Binder

Soft Card Sleeves

Standard Size Matte Card Sleeves

Black Standard Size Board Game Trading Card Sleeves

Perfect Fit Ultra Clear

Trading Card Toploader Holder

Trading Card Storage Pages

Features

Durable Sleeves With Minimal Glare

A Set of Toploaders and Soft Sleeves

Easy to Shuffle For Smooth Gameplay

Good Fit and Durable

Perfect to be Paired With Toploaders

Opaque Black Backs for Tournaments

Cards Fit Neatly Into the Sleeves and are Easy to Shuffle

Durable Sleeves for Smaller Cards

Thick Toploaders That Keep Cards in Place

Good for Standard-Sized Cards

Price$10.95$29.09$17.90$6.99$6.50$11.97$9.99$19.99$8.98$7.95
Sleeve typeSoftToploader and softSoftSheetsSoftSoftSoftSoftToploaderSheets
Number100100 toploaders, 100 soft30030 pages1001501504002532 pages
Size2.6 x 3.6 in.3 x 4 in.2.6 x 3.6 in.2.6 x 3.6 in.2.6 x 3.6 in.2.6 x 3.6 in.2.6 x 3.6 in.2.5 x 3.5 in.3 x 4 in.3.6 x 2.75 in.
Link

How to Choose a Trading Card Sleeve - Buying Guide

Before buying any trading card sleeves, there are a few points you should take into consideration. To help you with this, we've put together this handy buying guide!

Choose Between Soft, Toploader and Sheet Sleeves

It’s common to see trading card collections kept in binders, but these aren’t always the most convenient way to protect and store them. If you’re looking to protect your cards in a more individual way, then there are three main types of card sleeves.

Use Soft Sleeves for Games Like Pokemon and Magic the Gathering

Use Soft Sleeves for Games Like Pokemon and Magic the Gathering

Soft sleeves are individual sleeves made from thin, clear plastic that are roughly the same size as standard trading cards. They will protect the cards from fingerprints or dust but offer little protection against being bent.


For cards that are often used in games, such as Pokemon or Magic the Gathering cards, these are the best option. This type of sleeve will protect the card during play no matter how many times it is handled but isn't bulky like toploaders. It’s easy to take cards in and out and they’re usually sold in bulk, making it easier to protect an entire deck.


If you're going to be playing in tournaments, you can look at soft sleeves that have colored opaque backs. This will mask the back of your cards, so differences in decks or any marks on the cards won't be seen by your opponents!

Get Toploader Sleeves for Rare Variants and Special Cards

Get Toploader Sleeves for Rare Variants and Special Cards

These are also individual sleeves made from clear plastic, but they are far more rigid and thick than soft sleeves. They’re usually a little bigger than the standard trading card size and offer more complete protection. Their thickness can be measured in mils, with anything above 10 mil being a strong thickness.


If you have 1:1 cards, signature cards, or art cards, you’ll want the extra protection that toploaders give. They’ll not only protect these cards from fingerprints and dust, but their rigidity gives them protection against being bent.


However, if you looking for the best protection possible for your rare cards, then the best option is to use both soft sleeves and toploaders! Put the card in a soft sleeve first and then insert this - open end first - into a toploader sleeve. The card will be then completely encased in plastic.

Sheets for Pictures and to Keep Groups Together

Sheets for Pictures and to Keep Groups Together

These are like the pages you will find in binders, only they’re loose. Typically they have nine pockets that are standard trading card size and are of a similar quality to soft sleeves.


Sheets can be used to display a set of trading cards. Some cards have special backs that when put together, make a larger picture. A single sheet is a great way to organize these and show off the completed image!

Check the Size of the Sleeves and Your Cards

Check the Size of the Sleeves and Your Cards

Most cards and sleeves conform to the standard size of 3.5 inches by 2.5 inches. Typically, toploaders are a little larger and are four inches by three inches. However, not every card conforms to these sizes! Even some cards that are the standard size might not fit if they are too thick.


Some trading card collections have patch or medallion cards that are several times the thickness of regular cards, and these will not fit in soft sleeves. They may not even fit in toploaders! Before you buy any sleeves, check that your cards will fit.

Make Sure They’re Matte, Waterproof, and UV Protected

Make Sure They’re  Matte, Waterproof, and UV Protected

When buying soft sleeves for cards to be used in games, sleeves that have a matte finish are better than glossy ones. Matte sleeves will be easier to handle and are also less prone to glare.


Whatever type of sleeve you buy, look for ones that are waterproof. Plastic is naturally waterproof, but if the sleeves aren’t constructed neatly, it’s possible that water could soak through the edges or joins.


UV protection is another feature that will help protect your cards as it will stop them from fading due to the light. It’s also important to look for sleeves that are made out of safe materials. Many are acid-free and non-PVC, and these are the best options.

More Hobbies to Entertain You

More Hobbies to Entertain You

If you're looking for more hobbies you can do from the warmth and comfort of your home, we have some suggestions for you. Whether you're looking for solo hobbies or activities to do with friends and family, there are many options available!

Summary

We found that the best trading card sleeves depend on your purpose. If you're going to be handling your cars often as part of playing a game, then soft sleeves are the best. To protect valuable cards, such as rare variants or signatures, we suggest toploader sleeves.


The best trading card sleeves are durable, non-toxic, and can survive rough handling or accidents. We hope that no matter what trading card sleeves you choose, they protect your cards for years to come!


Author: Kellie Lacey


Related Articles

Popular Articles

  • Top 10 Best Oracle Decks in 2020 (Kim Krans, Rebecca Campbell, and More)
    Top 10 Best Oracle Decks in 2020 (Kim Krans, Rebecca Campbell, and More)
    In today's busy world, it can be easy to overlook self-reflection and self-care. Taking time to contemplate our thoughts, feelings, and experiences can help us see patterns, understand deeper meanings, and connect to our intuition.  An oracle deck may be just the thing you need to help refocus your energy and get a fresh perspective! And they come in so many styles that you're bound to find one you like.We searched high and low to find the best oracle decks to add to your self-care or spiritual practice. Our favorite is The Wild Unknown Animal Spirit Deck by New York Times bestselling artist Kim Krans. Whether used as daily inspiration or for a more in-depth reading, the archetypes depicted in these cards can help you gain a better understanding of yourself and the world around you. Keep reading for the rest of our top 10 decks and a useful buying guide!
    Hobbies
    6,087 views
  • Top 10 Best Terrarium Kits in 2021 (Hirt's Gardens and More)
    Top 10 Best Terrarium Kits in 2021 (Hirt's Gardens and More)
    Plants can brighten up any home! As well as looking good, they can also improve your mood and mental health. If you spend a lot of time inside or don't have access to a garden, then house plants become even more important. However, plants can take up much-needed space and require lots of care. Terrariums are mini-gardens that can be used to grow small plants indoors! Often small enough to sit neatly on your desk, they're easy to care for and add some greenery to any space. If you don't have space (or a green thumb), then a terrarium might be what you need! We looked at all of the terrarium kits available online and found that the best kit was TerraGreen Creations' Easy Grow Complete Fairy Garden Kit. It's easy to plant, cute, and comes with everything you need for your own terrarium. Keep reading for the rest of our favorites and a handy buying guide!
    Hobbies
    4,043 views
  • Top 10 Best 3D Puzzles for Adults in 2021 (Bepuzzled, Ravensburger, and More)
    Top 10 Best 3D Puzzles for Adults in 2021 (Bepuzzled, Ravensburger, and More)
    3D puzzles are a great way to challenge yourself and pass away the time - even for adults! But it can be a bit tricky to find the one that has the right balance between complexity and fun. To solve this issue, we looked at puzzles in wood, crystal, and foam; they were shaped like castles, pirate ships, and dragons. Along the way, we found that the best match what you’re looking for in terms of design, complexity, and size. Generally speaking, the hardest puzzles have more pieces, include moving parts, and come with detailed instructions. Keeping all these things in mind, we hand-picked a few that could double as works of art or feats of engineering, with Ukrainian Bridge taking our top spot.
    Hobbies
    9,339 views
  • Top 10 Best Jewelry Making Kits in 2021 (STMT, Kid Made Modern, and More)
    Top 10 Best Jewelry Making Kits in 2021 (STMT, Kid Made Modern, and More)
    Jewelry making can be one of the most rewarding forms of crafting, and the best place to start is with an all-in-one kit. That’s why we’ve scoured the internet and pored over reviews to find out what makes a great jewelry making kit.While researching, we found that the best jewelry making kits include all the necessary tools and pieces made from materials that work for your skin. Of course, they also make the kind of jewelry that you’re looking for, whether that be beaded necklaces or earrings. We especially loved BeautyBeads' Jewelry Making Kit for Adults, but we have even more great options in our top 10 list!
    Hobbies
    22,733 views
  • Top 10 Best Desktop Zen Gardens in 2020 (Toysmith, ICNBUYS, and More)
    Top 10 Best Desktop Zen Gardens in 2020 (Toysmith, ICNBUYS, and More)
    Sometimes, life feels like a game of whack-a-mole. You finish one thing, and something else pops up. You finish that thing, and then something else pops up. It’s a frustrating, dizzying, tear-inducing game, and you need to stop. Relax! Gaze upon a mini Zen garden.There’s something about ripples–maybe the way they seem to just flow on forever, freely–that’s supremely calming. This, all Zen gardens have in common. But–and here, we return to the practical side of things–every kit has its own features: from the kind of sand and rocks used to what little statues are included. Only once you know what’s out there (and know yourself) can you find the garden that speaks most directly to you, as the Toysmith Deluxe Zen Garden did for us.
    Hobbies
    13,207 views
  • Top 10 Best Robot Pets in 2020 (FurReal Friends, Joy for All, and More)
    Top 10 Best Robot Pets in 2020 (FurReal Friends, Joy for All, and More)
    Do you have a family member who's allergic to pet fur? Or maybe you just want a loveable companion for your children or one to be waiting at home for you after work. Robot pets are great for both situations, as they don't require much care, but they can offer a lot of play and affection.Of course, depending on who or what the pet is for, the form your robot is going to take will differ. We'll be going over 10 adorable and entertaining robot pets, including our favorite, Robotis Kidslab, before introducing you to important points to watch out for when choosing the best pet for you. Read on for more!
    Hobbies
    7,569 views
  • Top 10 Best Origami Papers in 2021 (Melissa & Doug, Tuttle Publishing, and More)
    Top 10 Best Origami Papers in 2021 (Melissa & Doug, Tuttle Publishing, and More)
    Looking for a fun craft project that's easy to learn? Try origami! Origami, or the art of paper folding, is a part of Japanese culture that has become incredibly popular in many parts of the world. You don't need any complicated tools; all you need is some origami paper. Origami paper is usually thinner than regular paper, and it holds shapes and creases much better. We researched the best origami papers available online, and our favorite product is Tuttle Publishing's Origami Paper. This set includes 500 sheets with traditional Japanese patterns, like flying cranes, waves, and cherry blossoms. Be sure to check out our top 10 list for more products that might pique your interest. We've also created a buying guide to help you with your selection process. 
    Hobbies
    85 views
  • Popular Item Lists

    Search by Category