• Top 10 Best Pie Plates in 2020 (Pyrex, OXO, and More) 1
  • Top 10 Best Pie Plates in 2020 (Pyrex, OXO, and More) 2
  • Top 10 Best Pie Plates in 2020 (Pyrex, OXO, and More) 3
  • Top 10 Best Pie Plates in 2020 (Pyrex, OXO, and More) 4
  • Top 10 Best Pie Plates in 2020 (Pyrex, OXO, and More) 5

Top 10 Best Pie Plates in 2020 (Pyrex, OXO, and More)

Do you love to bake? Pie plates are a portable baking tool for home use. They're versatile and come in various designs and sizes. Pie plates aren't just great for baking pies, but they also work well with other types of baked goods like cakes, bread, and even pizza!


That's why we've done our research and pored over reviews on Amazon to choose the 10 most highly recommended pie plates. The Easy Grab Pie Plates from Pyrex are our top pick because they're sturdy, bake evenly, and come with a warranty. Check out our top 10 for the rest of our favorites. On top of that, our buying guide will give you some suggestions on how to choose the right pie plate for you!

  • Last updated: 11-08-2020
  • 347 views
Table of Contents

Top 10 Best Pie Plates

Check out our top ten picks for pie plates, all of which are highly rated by reviewers! We've included products to suit all kinds of pies and baking needs. 

1

PyrexEasy Grab Pie Plates

2 pack

$18.00

MaterialGlass
Diameter9.5 in. each
Depth2 in.
2

Emile HenryModern Classics Pie Dish

$39.99

MaterialCeramic
Diameter9 in.
Depth2.5 in.
3

USA PanAluminized Steel Pie Pan

$14.99

MaterialAluminized steel
Diameter9 in.
Depth2 in.
4

MontopackDisposable Pie Plates

50 pack

$11.48

MaterialAluminum
Diameter5 in.
Depth5.5 in.
5

Anchor HockingMini Pie Plate Oven Basics

$16.99

MaterialGlass
Diameter6 in.
Depth1.75 in.
6

SweeseRound Pie Plate With a Ruffled Edge

$24.99

MaterialCeramic
Diameter9 in.
Depth2 in.
7

OXOGood Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid

$9.99

MaterialGlass, BPA-free plastic lid
Diameter9 in.
DepthAbout 2.5 in.
8

Chicago MetallicProfessional Non-Stick Split Decision Pie Pan

$14.99

MaterialAluminized steel
Diameter9 in.
Depth1.5 in.
9

Aunt Shannon's KitchenPorcelain Ceramic Individual Pie Pans

12 pack

$38.97

MaterialCeramic
Diameter6 in. each
Depth2 in.
10

Lindy'sStainless Steel Pie Pan

$5.99

MaterialStainless steel
Diameter9.75 in.
Depth1.5 in.

Compare the Best Pie Plates

Image
1
Pyrex Easy Grab Pie Plates 1

Pyrex

2
Emile Henry Modern Classics Pie Dish 1

Emile Henry

3
USA Pan Aluminized Steel Pie Pan 1

USA Pan

4
Montopack Disposable Pie Plates 1

Montopack

5
Anchor Hocking Mini Pie Plate Oven Basics 1

Anchor Hocking

6
Sweese Round Pie Plate With a Ruffled Edge 1

Sweese

7
OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid 1

OXO

8
Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Split Decision Pie Pan 1

Chicago Metallic

9
Aunt Shannon's Kitchen Porcelain Ceramic Individual Pie Pans  1

Aunt Shannon's Kitchen

10
Lindy's Stainless Steel Pie Pan 1

Lindy's

Name

Easy Grab Pie Plates

Modern Classics Pie Dish

Aluminized Steel Pie Pan

Disposable Pie Plates

Mini Pie Plate Oven Basics

Round Pie Plate With a Ruffled Edge

Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid

Professional Non-Stick Split Decision Pie Pan

Porcelain Ceramic Individual Pie Pans

Stainless Steel Pie Pan

Features

The Only Pie Plate You'll Ever Need

A Highly Heat-Resistant Plate Made of Natural Material

A Corrosion-Resistant, Non-Stick Coating Plate

Foil Pie Pans for Parties and Taking On the Go

A Small Glass Plate With Built-in Handles

A Beautiful Deep-Dish Pie Plate

A Standard Pie Plate With a Lid to Prevent Mess

2-In-1 Pie Plate With a Variety of Uses

Versatile, Freezer-to-Oven Safe Pie Pans

A Dishwasher-Safe, Tarnish-Resistant Pan

Price$18.00$39.99$14.99$11.48$16.99$24.99$9.99$14.99$38.97$5.99
MaterialGlassCeramicAluminized steelAluminumGlassCeramicGlass, BPA-free plastic lidAluminized steelCeramicStainless steel
Diameter9.5 in. each9 in.9 in.5 in.6 in.9 in.9 in.9 in.6 in. each9.75 in.
Depth2 in.2.5 in.2 in.5.5 in.1.75 in.2 in.About 2.5 in.1.5 in.2 in.1.5 in.
Link

How to Choose a Pie Plate - Buying Guide

You might think all pie plates are pretty much the same, but many are totally different! There are several little details that you should consider before making your decision.

Choose Between Different Pie Plate Materials

There are three main pie plate materials. One can conduct heat quickly, another can distribute heat evenly, and the third is perfect for frozen pies. 

Metal Plates Heat Up the Fastest and are Great for Blind-Baking

Metal Plates Heat Up the Fastest and are Great for Blind-Baking

Metal plates can heat up and cool down the fastest compared to other materials. However, we don't recommend them for lemon pies because metal can react with acidic ingredients, changing your food's color, odor, and taste. But, they are the best option for blind-baking, which is baking a pie crust without any filling. 


When it comes to metals, try to avoid a pie plate made of cast iron. Cast iron is quite heavy and requires specific patience. 


We recommend an aluminum or steel plate since these materials are lightweight and dishwasher-safe. Don't forget to consider a metal plate that comes with a scratch-proof, non-stick coating! This coating can also help prevent staining. 

Metal Plates Heat Up the Fastest and are Great for Blind-Baking

Disposable aluminum pie pans are made of durable aluminum that can handle heavy pies. Although they don't bake crusts as evenly as glass plates, they are the most convenient option for taking on the go. Since they're a little fragile, make sure to hold them with your hand centered on the bottom to keep the pies' shape.


If you want your baked goods brown on the bottom, we suggest choosing dull or darker-colored metals because they absorb heat quicker, resulting in lesser baking time. On the other hand, lighter-colored metals are a great option to keep a pie crust from browning too much and bake it more evenly.

Glass Plates are Versatile and Perfect for Anyone

Glass Plates are Versatile and Perfect for Anyone

Although glass plates don't conduct heat as quickly as metal plates, they distribute heat more evenly and continuously. With consistent heat, you'll get a perfect, golden-brown crust every time you bake. In terms of heat transfer, glass plates are safe to use with both microwave radiation and oven conduction. 


However, they can break easily, especially without proper use and care. The slippery texture can also cause a crust shrinkage when baking. To prevent this issue, make sure you rest your dough long enough and don't stretch it out fit into the plate. A small amount of baking soda can enable a crust to expand into a plate, too!

Glass Plates are Versatile and Perfect for Anyone

Many people prefer glass plates over other types because they're affordable, chemical-free, non-leaching, and odor-resistant. Since glass is a transparent material, it allows you to keep an eye on your food while it's baking, too! We highly recommend glass plates for all baking skill levels and kinds of pies.

Ceramic Plates are Beautiful and Freezer-to-Oven Safe

Ceramic Plates are Beautiful and Freezer-to-Oven Safe

Ceramic plates are generally the most expensive type of pie plate. They're quite similar to glass in terms of slowly conducting and evenly distributing heat.


Ceramic plates come in many beautiful designs and are freezer-to-oven safe. Freezing your pie before baking can prevent the crust from shrinking and becoming soggy. So, we recommend these plates for frozen pies, fruit pies, and pumpkin pies.


The two main concerns of ceramic plates are the size and the plate rim. Although its label may say the size is standard, they usually are slightly bigger and have a thicker rim. Consequently, make sure to prepare enough filling and choose the right baking time and temperature for your pie.

Get the Right Size Pie Plate for Your Recipes

Get the Right Size Pie Plate for Your Recipes

The most common pie plates are nine and 10 inches in diameter and one-and-a-half to two inches in depth. With these sizes, you'll need about four to six cups of pie filling.


If you're a beginner, it's a good idea to choose a standard nine-inch diameter because there are many easy recipes that you can follow. However, you'll need to think about the number of people you want to serve, too! Keep in mind that a standard pie pan can make six to eight servings


If you're looking to make savory pies or double-crust pies, we suggest a deep-dish pie plate; it's normally is two to two-and-a-half inches in depth. On the other hand, mini pie plates allow you to make different types of pies that are perfect for single servings. These mini sizes generally range from four to six inches in diameter.  

Pick a Pie Plate Shape That Works for You

Pick a Pie Plate Shape That Works for You

Although pie plates look similar, they're different in some ways. In addition to your color preference, the design of the rim is another important thing to consider.


A flat rim has a simple design and is suitable for all kinds of pies. With this shape, you can easily remove a pie from the plate without damaging the crust. On the other hand, a fluted rim creates a beautiful shape and makes a pie crust looks more professional.


If you're a beginner, it's a good idea to choose a pie plate with a wider rim to reduce the amount of shrinkage once the crust is in the oven. We suggest ones that come with an edge of at least half of an inch.

Looking For More Baking Equipment?

Looking For More Baking Equipment?

There are many types of baking equipment that you can add to your kitchen! Check out our suggestions to determine which types of tools and bakeware will be best for your baked goods.

Summary

Whether you're a beginner looking to make a pie for the first time or an experienced baker looking to improve your skills, we've got you covered! We recommend keeping in mind three things when buying pie plates: the sizes of the plate, the plate material, and the edge of the pie crust. 


You'll want a pie plate that's easy to use and gives you the best results, too. If you keep these factors in mind, choosing the right pie plate that meets your needs will be easy!


Author: Apinya Masuda


Related Articles

Popular Articles

  • Top 10 Best Hot Pot Cookers in 2021 (Aroma, Cooks, and More)
    Top 10 Best Hot Pot Cookers in 2021 (Aroma, Cooks, and More)
    There’s nothing more comforting on a cold winter night than sitting around a table with your friends and family eating food that you all cooked together. And there’s no better way to do that than hot pot! From broths filled with mouth-numbing Chinese Szechuan peppers to mild Japanese shabu shabu, hot pot is fun, instant, and easy to do at home—if you have the right materials.As the popularity of this traditional Asian cooking style continues to rise in the West, so does the availability of electric and stovetop cookers in small and large sizes. But choosing is difficult, so that’s why we’ve put together this quick guide to picking out the right hot pot cooker. We’ve also included a list of our ten favorite hot pots—split into electric and non-electric categories—to start your search. We personally loved Aroma's Housewares 3-in-1 Super Pot for its versatility and portability!
    Kitchen supplies
    54,553 views
  • Top 23 Best Japanese Rice Storage Containers to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 23 Best Japanese Rice Storage Containers to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    To make sure our precious rice is free from things like insects, dust, and humidity, we need a container capable of protecting it. Recently, we've seen a lot of new designs as well as slimmer models capable of fitting tightly inside one's refrigerator. But just which ones stand out above the rest?Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites like Amazon, Rakuten, and Yahoo! Shopping for the 23 most popular rice storage containers. Then we put them to the test!We tested each product for the following 2 criteria. Sealing StrengthUsabilityFinally, we created a buying guide to help you choose the best rice container out there. So, which one will stand out above the rest? Use this article as a reference to help you make your purchase.
    Kitchen supplies
    7,554 views
  • Top 10 Best Reusable Ice Cubes in 2021 (Kikkerland, ODS, and More)
    Top 10 Best Reusable Ice Cubes in 2021 (Kikkerland, ODS, and More)
    It’s summer, it’s hot, and you just want a cold drink. But unless you’re just drinking water, it’s hard to ignore the fact that your melting ice cubes water down your drinks and change the flavor! Luckily, there are reusable ice cubes that don’t melt away and can be used over and over. But there are also a ton of different options, and it can be hard to figure out which one is the best for you.That’s where we come in! In this guide, we’ll run through a few things you should consider when choosing reusable ice cubes, and if you still find yourself stuck, we’ve also got ten of our favorites (like Blue3D's Reusable Plastic Ice Cubes) to help make the decision a little easier.
    Kitchen supplies
    21,181 views
  • Top 10 Best Matcha Tea Sets in 2020 (Bambooworx, Jade Leaf Matcha, and More)
    Top 10 Best Matcha Tea Sets in 2020 (Bambooworx, Jade Leaf Matcha, and More)
    Matcha has long been appreciated for its multiple health benefits, including promoting brain activity, weight loss, and improving alertness. Making the beverage can be difficult, though, when the powder is so fine and doesn't dissolve well in water. A matcha tea set with specially designed tools for making the perfect drink comes in handy here.Maybe you're just looking to make your daily cup of green tea nice and smooth, or maybe you're curious about the Japanese Tea Ceremony - we've got you covered with all the information you need when choosing your set. Our top pick was the Matcha Whisk Set by BambooMN for its simplicity, reliability, and its attention to detail used to craft its tea ladle. Read on for more information about what else made the cut! 
    Kitchen supplies
    4,963 views
  • Top 10 Best Egg Yolk Separators in 2021 (OXO, Tovolo, and More)
    Top 10 Best Egg Yolk Separators in 2021 (OXO, Tovolo, and More)
    Looking for easy ways to separate eggs? If so, you've come to the right place. Many people buy a separator for a convenient purpose. However, not all separators are created equal! Some will help you to easily and quickly separate the eggs without a mess, whereas others can break the yolk and tend to be more time-consuming for the egg white to flow out. If you want to know how to choose a good separator that meets all your needs, don't miss this article full of helpful advice in our buying guide below. We recommend starting with the egg yolk separator from Soleader because it's made with high-quality material, offers an instant separation, and comes with a long anti-slip handle that allows you to rest over a bowl. For more great options, browse our top 10 list!
    Kitchen supplies
    65 views
  • Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Food Storage Containers in 2020 (Weck, Bklyn, and More)
    Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Food Storage Containers in 2020 (Weck, Bklyn, and More)
    Everybody knows that single-use plastics are bad for the environment, but in reality, all plastics are pretty terrible. So when it’s time to replace your food containers, instead of reaching for the first plastic container you see on the shelf, it might be a better idea to think about the wider impact your purchase will have.But even if you exclude plastics from your search, there are still so many options when it comes to food storage containers. So in this guide, we’ll go over the different things you should look out for when picking an eco-friendly food storage container. We’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites for you to start your search, including our number one, Bklyn Bento.
    Kitchen supplies
    8,432 views
  • Top 10 Best Tart Pans in 2020 (Wilton, Le Creuset, and More)
    Top 10 Best Tart Pans in 2020 (Wilton, Le Creuset, and More)
    Tart pans can be used to bake tarts and quiches, but they also make a good substitute for pie pans, too! Some tart pans can heat up quickly and cook evenly while others offer a non-stick coating for easy cleaning. There are plenty of options, and you may find yourself wondering which ones are the best.Read on for our buying guide that's packed with useful information on how to choose the best tart pans. On top of that, we have selected the 10 most popular tart pans that you should consider. The Wilton Excelle Elite is our top-ranking product because it's made of high-quality material, comes with a removable bottom, and offers a 10-year warranty. Want to know more? Check out the rest of the products on our list!
    Kitchen supplies
    676 views
  • Popular Item Lists

    Search by Category