mybest
Beds and bedding

Helping You Find the Best

Close
  1. TOP
  2. Interior
  3. Beds and bedding
  4. 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More)
  • 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More) 1
  • 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More) 2
  • 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More) 3
  • 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More) 4
  • 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More) 5

10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More)

Maybe you have allergies, or maybe you're trying to ward off bed bugs or mold. When you can't afford an entirely new mattress, a mattress protector is a valid solution. We'll tell you why you should invest in one and how you can find one to fit your mattress size (whether it be king, queen, full, or twin). We've also narrowed down a list of the best mattress protectors available online.

Last updated 03/15/2024
mybest US Editors
Guide
Editing Dept.
mybest US Editors

mybest US' editing team consists of experienced members who have backgrounds in writing, editing, translation, and more. We are dedicated to researching what makes a product or service the best to users in the US in order to create top-quality articles. From skincare, to kitchen appliances, and to DIY supplies, our mission is to find the best ones for you.

mybest US Editors's Profile
…Continue reading

Table of Contents

Why You Should Invest in a Mattress Protector

You might have spent a lot on your favorite mattress and expect it to last long. However, do you think you are protecting your mattress enough to keep unwanted elements at bay? 


Well, no one wants their mattress to lose comfort and become uncomfortable to sleep on after a few months of usage. Here are some reasons why you should invest in a mattress protector.

It Provides Basic Protection for Your Expensive Mattress

It Provides Basic Protection for Your Expensive Mattress

You might not have kids or pets at home, or you do not have the habit of bringing liquids to bed. That does not mean your mattress remains protected for years. 


Regular usage can damage any mattress if not protected and handled properly. A mattress protector is all that you need to safeguard your mattress from regular wear and tear and to get a comfortable sleep.

It Protects Your Mattress from Liquid Spills, Accidents, and Moisture Damage

It Protects Your Mattress from Liquid Spills, Accidents, and Moisture Damage
Source:amazon.com

Liquid spillage on mattresses is a common problem as young children are prone to accidental spillage and bed wetting. People with children at home should protect their mattresses using a good-quality mattress protector.


Some people sweat excessively at night - mattresses absorb the unwanted moisture and body oils, thereby damaging it in the long run. To avoid causing moisture damage to mattresses, especially the foam types, guard it with a waterproof protector

It Offers Intense Protection from Allergens and Dust Mites

It Offers Intense Protection from Allergens and Dust Mites

No matter how clean a house is, dust settles in every corner. The infestation of dust mites commonly goes unnoticed, and they grow tremendously in humid and warm environments. 


Instead of dealing with these and other allergies you may have, have a mattress protector that can keep dust mites at bay and give you a better night's sleep.

It Defends against Bed Bugs

It Defends against Bed Bugs

It’s easy for anyone to come in contact with bed bugs. The insects can find their way into clothes and luggage, eventually getting transported to your home. They can then settle in mattresses and carpets, breeding their way into building a kingdom inside your house. (Nice image, right?)


As these insects thrive well in warm weather conditions and come with good cold tolerance, you need to protect yourself and your mattress from possible infestations. A fully encased protector with bedbug barriers will be essential for those who travel frequently or get exposed to unclean environments. 

How to Choose Mattress Protector

Buying a mattress protector makes sense when you consider all that it can safeguard you against, especially when you spend one-third of a day on it. Read on to find what you need to consider before buying a protector for your valuable mattress. 

1

① Different Materials Offer Different Levels of Protection

Mattress protectors are commonly available in cotton and polyester. Some waterproof protectors can protect the mattress from liquid spills and sweat. 


The right material for your protector will depend on the features they come with and the comfort they can offer. Some protectors come with just one fabric, and some come with one material for top layer and another for the bottom layer. Find which one is best for you.

Go with Cotton for Basic Protection and Great Comfort

Go with Cotton for Basic Protection and Great Comfort

A simple cotton mattress protector is enough for basic protection from allergens and dust mites. They are lightweight and are machine-washable. Waterproof protection can be added to cotton to prevent liquids from entering the mattress. 


Some cotton protectors come quilted with latex, wool, or down stuffing. Wool-stuffed protectors have moisture-wicking properties that make them ideal for summer months. A high-quality cotton protector can be expensive, but is worth the buy. The most common form of cotton protector comes with cotton terry fabric. 

Wool is Soft, Durable, and Comfortable

Wool is Soft, Durable, and Comfortable

Wool mattress protectors can be warm and cozy and are easily washable. Besides, they can prevent body oils and sweat from getting accumulated on your mattress. 


Organic wool is known for its great thermal efficiency - it can keep you warmer in winters and cooler in summers. The best wool protectors come with eco-friendly or 100% natural wool and tend to have a higher price tag, but the protection is worth it. 

Polyester is Lightweight and Easy to Wash

Polyester is Lightweight and Easy to Wash
Source:amazon.com

Polyester protectors are thinner than cotton and are lightweight protectors, making them easier to wash and maintain. They are good at wicking moisture and sweat easily, and can dry up fast at the same time. 


However, they can be uncomfortable since they can heat up quickly - making them not ideal for warm summer months. Since they retain odor, you need to frequently wash it, unlike a cotton protector that needs less maintenance. Polyester covers are great for those on a budget that have the time to commit to its upkeep.

Resist Those Spills with Vinyl and Polyurethane Backing

Resist Those Spills with Vinyl and Polyurethane Backing
Source:amazon.com

Vinyl can feel like plastic but it's water and stain-resistant; and protectors made of vinyl can be easily cleaned by wiping with a cloth. However, the use of a hazardous type of vinyl like PVC (polyvinyl chloride), releases toxins into the air that are harmful to pregnant women and children. 


PVC also contains phthalates that can cause many health hazards. Go with vinyl-free mattress protectors that use a better alternative like polyurethane backing for waterproof qualities. Polyurethane (PU) is a breathable material, and mattresses made of PU produce less friction and noise inside the bedsheet.

Memory Foam and Down-Feather Protectors for Comfort Like Never Before

Memory Foam and Down-Feather Protectors for Comfort Like Never Before
Source:amazon.com

There are also memory foam mattress protectors that can improve the feel of an old, hard mattress. Featherbed mattress protectors can bring you to a whole new level of comfort, too! While memory foam protectors can easily mold to the shape of your body, and featherbed types are great for pressure-point relief. Some come with a combination of down and feather. 


However, these mattress protectors are not that common. Despite being pricey, they are bought mainly for the unique comfort and feel they offer. Due to their heat absorption and retention properties, these materials are not ideal for those who struggle to keep their body cool at night. 

2

② Choose a Size That Fits Your Mattress the Right Way

② Choose a Size That Fits Your Mattress the Right Way

Mattress protectors are available in all sizes that standards mattresses are available at, including but not limited to King, California King, Queen, Full XL, Full, Twin XL, and Twin. Also available are protectors for the crib and mini crib mattresses. 


Measure the size of your mattress before buying a protector. The right size protector will stay in place and does not bunch up under the bedsheet. Also measure the height of the mattress, so you can find a protector that is not too short for the mattress.

3

③ Choose the Right Fit and Type for Your Lifestyle

Mattress protectors are of different styles and not all come with complete protection. Some are designed to cover the entire mattress, which makes them ideal for people who keeps flipping their mattress. They are available in fitted sheet style, encasement style, and basic elastic strap style. 

Zippered Protectors Offer Complete Protection

Zippered Protectors Offer Complete Protection
Source:amazon.com

Zippered mattress protectors are ideal for protecting the entire mattress. They can be covered firmly and closed using a zipper. If you have the habit of flipping and using your mattress, then this is the protector for you. 

Fitted Types to Just Fit In

Fitted Types to Just Fit In

These look like fitted sheets with pocketed corners and elastic edges. You can easily tuck them into the four corners and sides of the mattress. They are cheaper than the zippered ones; they're ideal for waterproof type mattress protectors


Fitted sheet style protector is very common, and is suitable for those who do not flip their mattress often. 

Elastic Straps for Those Who Only Need Top Cover Protection

Elastic Straps for Those Who Only Need Top Cover Protection
Source:amazon.com

A protector with elastic straps will just lay on top of your mattress to give extra comfort and protection. It comes with straps on four corners that can be easily fastened around the mattress. 


Although it provides a firmer and tighter fitting than a fitted sheet style protector, it cannot cover all sides of your mattress. This leaves your mattress exposed to dust, damage, and insects infestations. Go with an elastic one if you want something that's easy to put on and you don't need a ton of protection.

4

④ Consider Other Factors Like Washing Methods, Ventilation, and Allergies Maximum Comfort and Convenience

While you carefully consider properties that can safeguard your mattress and offer a comfortable sleep, a few other important factors should not be missed out. Check if you are allergic to the material, if it allows enough air circulation inside, and if it can be easily cleaned and maintained. 

Got Allergies? Find a Hypoallergenic Protector

Got Allergies? Find a Hypoallergenic Protector

Not all materials are hypoallergenic to keep allergens at bay. Multi-layered fabrics that have hypoallergenic features can be helpful if you are suffering from respiratory illnesses such as asthma or skin allergies such as eczema.


They are mostly paired with a primary material like cotton, and minimize your risk of exposure to substances causing allergic reaction through your mattress. Also look for mattresses that have hypoallergenic certifications like those from Oeko-TEX.

Find A Fabric that is Breathable and Comfortable

Find A Fabric that is Breathable and Comfortable

Breathable materials can allow air to pass through resulting in better moisture absorption and preventing dust and mildew from accumulating. 


Always go with premium protectors that offer breathability and comfort. Protectors with multiple layers can add extra cushion and comfort to the mattress. While some layered protectors can keep you warm, those wanting to feel cool can go for cooling protectors equipped with gel fibers that can absorb heat faster than other materials or fabrics. 


Vinyl protectors feel like plastic and can make noise while you move around in your sleep, which can cause sleep disruption. Protectors made of blended synthetics or cotton can eliminate this discomfort. 

Consider the Ease of Washing and Maintenance

Consider the Ease of Washing and Maintenance

All mattress protectors require regular washing and cleaning to keep your mattress optimally protected. Hand washing takes a lot of time and effort, so go for machine-washable protectors. They are easy to remove stains, dirt, and odors instantly. 

Was the Buying Guide helpful?

10 Best Mattress Protector Ranking

Here are the best Mattress Protector, ranked according to 10 Best Mattress Protectors (as of 11-04-2022). The products are ranked independently by mybest.
Popularity
Products
Image
Click to purchase
Price
Key features
1

SureGuard

SureGuard Waterproof Mattress Encasement

SureGuard SureGuard Waterproof Mattress Encasement 1

$59.97

Mid

360 Degree Protection for Optimum Sleeping Conditions

2

MALOUF

Wool Protector and Pad for Twin Mattresses

MALOUF Wool Protector and Pad for Twin Mattresses  1

$159.99

High Mid

100% Natural Wool Mattress Protector for Excellent Temperature Regulation

3

One's Own

Organic Tencel/Eucalyptus Fiber Top Mattress Protector

One's Own  Organic Tencel/Eucalyptus Fiber Top Mattress Protector 1

$91.97

High Mid

The Best Eco-friendly Mattress Protector

4

SafeRest

Premium Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Mattress Protector

SafeRest Premium Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Mattress Protector 1

$34.95

Low Mid

The Best Mattress Protector on a Budget

5

Sleep Innovations

Memory Foam Topper and Waterproof Mattress Protector

Sleep Innovations Memory Foam Topper and Waterproof Mattress Protector 1

$198.97

High

The Best Memory Foam Mattress Protector

6

Coop Home Goods

Oeko-TEX Certified Bamboo Queen Mattress Protector

Coop Home Goods Oeko-TEX Certified Bamboo Queen Mattress Protector 1

$44.99

Mid

The Best Oeko-TEX Certified Mattress Protector with a Money-back Guarantee

7

puredown

Premium White Goose Down Feather Topper for Protection

puredown Premium White Goose Down Feather Topper for Protection 1

$119.99

High Mid

A Down Mattress Protector That's Easy to Set up

8

Utopia Bedding

Encasement Waterproof Mattress Protector

Utopia Bedding Encasement Waterproof Mattress Protector 1

$27.99

Low Mid

The Best Budget-friendly Protector for Traditional Mattresses

9

UltraBlock

Cool and Comfortable UltraPlush Futon Mattress Protector

UltraBlock Cool and Comfortable UltraPlush Futon Mattress Protector 1

$39.95

Low Mid

The Best Protector for Futon Mattresses

10

Fabugears

Quilted Mattress Pad

Fabugears Quilted Mattress Pad 1

$23.99

Low Mid

The Ultimate Travel Mattress Protector

If you don't see the product you're looking for, you can request that it be listed.
No.1

SureGuardSureGuard Waterproof Mattress Encasement

SureGuard Waterproof Mattress Encasement 1
Source:amazon.com
SureGuard Waterproof Mattress Encasement 2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$59.97
Mid
Reference price
$59.97
Mid

360 Degree Protection for Optimum Sleeping Conditions

This protector from SureGuard comes with a zippered closure to completely seal off your mattress and to provide it with a bedbug barrier. This makes it a great cover to protect your mattress from allergens and insect infestation. 


The cotton terry makes it soft on the body and can wick away moisture and sweat effectively. The high-quality fabric also makes it recommendable for those allergic to most mattresses and protector materials. 


As with all mattress protectors, it may take some work to put it on. Some reviewers expressed the need for two people to set it up.

Was this Ranking helpful?
No.2

MALOUFWool Protector and Pad for Twin Mattresses

Wool Protector and Pad for Twin Mattresses  1
Source:amazon.com
Wool Protector and Pad for Twin Mattresses  2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$159.99
High Mid
Reference price
$159.99
High Mid

100% Natural Wool Mattress Protector for Excellent Temperature Regulation

Looking for a mattress protector with the comfort of extra cushion? This is it. The wool cover makes it thermal efficient, just enough to keep you warm in winter months and cool in summer months. 


Besides great temperature control, the breathable protector comes with great absorption capacity thanks to its H2Pro membrane polyurethane layer. 


The soft feel of wool makes it extremely cozy to sleep on, while it also wards your mattress away from allergens and dust mites. You can use it on mattresses of up to 22 inches thickness. 


However, the product might not be for those looking for a thicker and bouncy feel of a mattress pad. Being on the flatter side, it works better as a protector and than a pad.

No.3

One's Own Organic Tencel/Eucalyptus Fiber Top Mattress Protector

Organic Tencel/Eucalyptus Fiber Top Mattress Protector 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$91.97
High Mid
Reference price
$91.97
High Mid

The Best Eco-friendly Mattress Protector

This protector from One's Own boasts of an environment-friendly way of protecting your mattress with its 100% eucalyptus fibers that can wick away moisture and body oils - great for those looking for protection without hurting the environment. 


The TPU waterproof backing is micro-porous enabling enough air circulation and also blocking the growth of mildew and other allergens.


The ultra-deep side skirts can cover mattresses of any depth. But be careful while tugging, as it might cause the fibers to tear.


And although it creates an inhospitable environment for dust mites and allergens, reviewers state that it might bunch up under the bedsheet. Tuck the side skirts well for a snug fit, and it might solve the issue. 

No.4

SafeRestPremium Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Mattress Protector

Premium Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Mattress Protector 1
Source:amazon.com
Premium Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Mattress Protector 2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$34.95
Low Mid
Reference price
$34.95
Low Mid

The Best Mattress Protector on a Budget

This premium mattress protector comes with optimum features to ward off allergens from infesting your mattress. Its cotton terry back absorbs moisture and the 100% waterproof membrane layer repels liquids.


The breathable protector enables good air circulation inside the layers leaving no worry about unpleasant smells and mildew formation. 


However, some reviews expressed dissatisfaction over its performance after a couple of years, particularly cat owners whose pets wet the bed. You might be better off with something more waterproof.

No.5

Sleep InnovationsMemory Foam Topper and Waterproof Mattress Protector

Memory Foam Topper and Waterproof Mattress Protector 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$198.97
High
Reference price
$198.97
High

The Best Memory Foam Mattress Protector

This product is a wonderful concept from Sleep Innovations to give you the comfort of a memory foam mattress topper with added protection from a fiber-filled waterproof protector


The fitted sheet style protector can stretch to fit mattress thickness of up to 15 inches of any Twin XL mattress.  


Although machine-washable, it is good to wash the memory foam topper under running water, which can be a bit inconvenient. Machine washing can crunch and break up the foam. 

No.6

Coop Home GoodsOeko-TEX Certified Bamboo Queen Mattress Protector

Oeko-TEX Certified Bamboo Queen Mattress Protector 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$44.99
Mid
Reference price
$44.99
Mid

The Best Oeko-TEX Certified Mattress Protector with a Money-back Guarantee

This mattress protector with Oeko-TEX certification protects you against common allergens like dust, pet dander, bacteria, and more.


Its superior waterproof membrane protects your valuable mattress from usual damages caused by body fluids, sweat, accidental spills, and moisture. The fabric is soft and breathable and comes with an impressive money-back guarantee if you are not satisfied in 100 days. 


Reviewers had expressed concern over its ability to hold liquid spills. If machine wash instructions are followed well, you can maintain its comfort and properties for a long time. 

No.7

puredownPremium White Goose Down Feather Topper for Protection

Premium White Goose Down Feather Topper for Protection 1
Source:amazon.com
Premium White Goose Down Feather Topper for Protection 2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$119.99
High Mid
Reference price
$119.99
High Mid

A Down Mattress Protector That's Easy to Set up

This protective cover is made with 75% goose down and 25% goose feather stuffed inside a cotton fabric cover. It's equipped with elastic straps on the four corners, making it easy to set up


Although it provides only the top protection from dust and allergens, the comfort and support that it gives are unparalleled - great for those fussy sleepers who need an extremely soft surface to sleep on. 


According to some reviews, the product needs regular fluffing to retain the softness and comfort claimed by the manufacturer. 

No.8

Utopia BeddingEncasement Waterproof Mattress Protector

Encasement Waterproof Mattress Protector 1
Source:amazon.com
Encasement Waterproof Mattress Protector 2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$27.99
Low Mid
Reference price
$27.99
Low Mid

The Best Budget-friendly Protector for Traditional Mattresses

This stretchable encasement protector is made of knitted polyester for extra comfort for you to lay on. The 360-degree protection and affordable price is what earned it a spot in our Top 10 list. 


Even better, Oeko-TEX Certification also ensures total protection from bed bugs, dust mites, and other allergens. 


However, according to some customers, the fit is not right for memory foam mattresses. That makes it an ideal choice to use with pillow-top mattresses. 

No.9

UltraBlockCool and Comfortable UltraPlush Futon Mattress Protector

Cool and Comfortable UltraPlush Futon Mattress Protector 1
Source:amazon.com
Cool and Comfortable UltraPlush Futon Mattress Protector 2
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$39.95
Low Mid
Reference price
$39.95
Low Mid

The Best Protector for Futon Mattresses

The use of micro-velour fibers makes this futon mattress protector more comfortable than regular cotton terry protectors. 


Its natural fibers absorb sweat and moisture effectively, besides creating a protective barrier against dust mites and allergens. The side skirts easily fit around the edges and corners of futon mattresses of up to 12 inches thick.


According to some reviewers, the waterproof backing can be a little difficult to wash. Since it might come out of the washer in a soaking wet condition, dry it with a dry bath towel to absorb the excess liquid.

No.10

FabugearsQuilted Mattress Pad

Quilted Mattress Pad 1
Source:amazon.com
Reference price
$23.99
Low Mid
Reference price
$23.99
Low Mid

The Ultimate Travel Mattress Protector

This mattress protector is designed to suit your travel needs, making it ideal to carry with you while camping, glamping, or sleeping on vehicles. 


It's great for those who have an allergic reaction to beds used in Amtrak or cabin beds inside buses. The dimensions are perfect for small mattresses and can block most dirt, dust, and moisture


It's thin enough to fold and carry, yet gives the best comfort you need during your travel. However, we recommend using a bed sheet on top to prevent the protector from moving or bunching in the night.  

Top 5 Mattress Protector

No. 1: SureGuardSureGuard Waterproof Mattress Encasement

No. 2: MALOUFWool Protector and Pad for Twin Mattresses

No. 3: One's Own Organic Tencel/Eucalyptus Fiber Top Mattress Protector

No. 4: SafeRestPremium Hypoallergenic and Waterproof Mattress Protector

No. 5: Sleep InnovationsMemory Foam Topper and Waterproof Mattress Protector

View Full Ranking
The descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
  1. TOP
  2. Interior
  3. Beds and bedding
  4. 10 Best Mattress Protectors of 2024 (SureGuard, SafeRest, and More)

Search by category

mybest

We connect users with the best tried and true products,
tested by our in-house guides and backed by expert insight.

Copyright mybest All Rights Reserved.