• Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online 2019 1
  • Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online 2019 2
  • Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online 2019 3
  • Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online 2019 4
  • Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online 2019 5

Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online 2019

Here's a predicament you may have faced at some point: you want to try deep-frying your Thanksgiving turkey, but you don't want to go down in history as the one who messed up when frying it. There are so many options to consider - should you get a propane or electric fryer? Stainless steel or aluminum? And what extra features do you need?


We're here to give you a rundown on what you should be looking for in our handy buying guide: the power source, the material, the size, and all the extra features. At the end, we've got a list of 7 of our favorite products to help you get started in your turkey fryer search, as well as some tips on how to fry your turkey safely.

  • Last updated: 11-08-2019
  • 39 views
Table of Contents

Top 7 Best Turkey Fryers to Buy Online

Here are the best turkey fryers we found online, and we think you'll find them great too. Be sure you read the reviews along with our advice when making your final decision.

1

MasterbuiltButterball Electric Fryer, XL Stainless Steel

MB23010618

$121.96

Size16.3 x 18.3 x 14.8 inches
Capacityup to a 20 lb. turkey
Power sourceElectric
MaterialStainless steel
Thermometer includedNo
Extra featuresMagnetic breakaway cord, oil drain valve, drain clips, digital timer, dishwasher safe components
2

Char-BroilThe Big Easy TRU-Infrared Oil-Less Turkey Fryer

$182.50

Size16 x 16 x 24.5 inches
Capacityup to a 16 lb. turkey
Power sourcePropane
Material-
Thermometer includedYes
Extra featuresCooking basket, lifter, quick start cooking guide, drip tray
3

Bayou ClassicStainless-Steel 32-Quart Turkey-Fryer Kit

1195

$249.99

Size18 x 19 x 22 inches
Capacityup to a 18 lb. turkey
Power sourcePropane
MaterialStainless steel
Thermometer includedYes
Extra featuresChicken frying skewer set, grab hook, perforated steam/boil basket
4

MasterbuiltButterball Oil Free Roaster Electric Fryer

MB23010809

$89.99

Size16.4 x 16.45 x 16.9 inches
CapacityUp to a 18 lb. turkey
Power sourceElectric
Material-
Thermometer includedNo
Extra featuresWood chip box, drip tray, magnetic breakaway cord, thermostat temperature control
5

Cooper & CoBackyard Pro Deluxe Aluminum Turkey Fryer Steamer Kit

$113.21

Size13.5 x 33 inches
Capacity30 quarts
Power sourcePropane
MaterialAluminum
Thermometer includedYes
Extra featuresTurkey hangar, sauce syringe, aluminum fry pan, aluminum basket, lifting hook
6

PrestoProfry Electric Rotisserie Turkey Fryer

05487

$95.74

Size15 x 22 x 15 inches
CapacityUp to a 15 lb. turkey
Power sourceElectric
MaterialStainless steel
Thermometer includedNo
Extra featuresSpatter-shield cover, adjustable thermostat, ready indicator light
7

CuisinartExtra-Large Rotisserie Deep Fryer

CDF-500

$161.93

Size20.2 x 16 x 16.4 inches
CapacityUp to a 14 lb. turkey
Power sourceElectric
MaterialStainless steel
Thermometer includedNo
Extra features120-minute timer, adjustable temperature control, stainless steel mesh basket

How to Choose a Turkey Fryer - Buying Guide

Frying a turkey isn't exactly the safest endeavor, but it can save you a lot of cooking time and space that you could be using to cook your many Thanksgiving side dishes. Choosing a fryer that fits your environment, turkey size, and budget will help narrow down possible candidates.

Decide What Kind of Power Source You Need

Most turkey fryers use either propane or electricity as their source of power. Here are the pros and cons of each type.

Propane Fryers are Great for Experts to Cook Outdoors

Propane Fryers are Great for Experts to Cook Outdoors

Propane fryers require you to connect the fryer to a propane tank with a hose. Since propane and high heat are involved, this should only be used outdoors. And since they can only be used outdoors, you need to consider the weather and whether you have enough space to use the fryer safely.


They can get the frying job done pretty quickly since the oil heats up fast, but many people find it hard to control the temperature of a propane fryer. There have been cases of the oil heating up to combustion, so only someone who’s used to frying should use a propane fryer.

Electric Fryers are Versatile, Safe, and Can Be Used by Beginners

Electric Fryers are Versatile, Safe, and Can Be Used by Beginners

If this is your first turkey frying journey, we’d highly recommend an electric fryer. They are often safer than propane fryers since many come with a breakaway cord that disconnects in the event of accidental tipping or oil spills.


Electric fryers can be used both outdoors and indoors, so weather isn’t an issue as long as you have a safe place to do your frying job. They also tend to come with more helpful features like thermometers and automatic shut off timers.

Choose Between a Stainless Steel or Aluminum Fryer

Choose Between a Stainless Steel or Aluminum Fryer

Turkey fryers are generally made with either stainless steel or aluminum. Stainless steel fryers tend to be more expensive, but they are easier to clean and they tend to last longer than fryers made of other materials. 


The most common alternative to stainless steel is aluminum. It may not last as long as a stainless steel fryer, but they tend to be easier on your wallet.

Match the Fryer to Your Turkey Size and Available Cooking Time

Unless this is your first attempt at cooking a Thanksgiving turkey or you're cooking for a new crowd this year, you've probably already decided what kind of turkey you're going to get and how much time you have to cook it. These are both very important factors to consider when looking at fryers.

Know What Size Your Turkey Will Be Before Buying a Fryer

Know What Size Your Turkey Will Be Before Buying a Fryer

The maximum capacity of a turkey fryer should be listed in the product description. Check this before making your purchase and compare it to the size of your Thanksgiving turkey.


We recommend buying a fryer that has a slightly higher capacity than your turkey; so if you’re buying a turkey that’s 12 lbs, consider a fryer that can handle up to 15 lbs. This allows for extra room in the fryer for your turkey to cook, and it also helps prevent accidental oil spills.

For Electric Fryers, a Higher Wattage Means Faster Cook Time

For Electric Fryers, a Higher Wattage Means Faster Cook Time

Part of the appeal of frying a turkey is a shorter cooking time than a conventional oven. For instance, some fryers can cook a 15 pound turkey in an hour while others take 2 hours to cook a 12 pound one. If you’re considering an electric fryer, you can find how fast you can cook a turkey by reading customer reviews or looking at the product’s wattage.

Extra Features Like Thermometers and Timers Could Save Your Turkey (and Your Life)

Extra Features Like Thermometers and Timers Could Save Your Turkey (and Your Life)

Frying a turkey isn’t exactly the safest endeavor, but there are features that can make or break a safe Thanksgiving. Look for a fryer that has features like a built-in thermometer, a vented lid to prevent overheating, an automatic shut-off timer, and more.


Other useful features like nonstick coating and oil drain holes can make cleanup much easier and safer as well.

How to Fry a Turkey Safely - Safety Tips

Hot oil can make things taste utterly delicious, but it's also extremely dangerous to work with. Whether this is your first deep-frying experience or you want a quick brush-up on safety measures, we've included this section to make your cooking journey as safe as possible.

Get That Turkey as Dry as Possible

Get That Turkey as Dry as Possible

We don't mean dry out the turkey meat itself; we mean the outside part. Most people buy turkeys frozen, and when meat thaws, it releases moisture. This moisture could cause painful and messy oil splatters when you dip it into the fryer.


To prevent this from happening, we recommend thawing the turkey as much as possible before starting the frying process. You should also pat the outside of the turkey with a towel, and don't be shy about it. It will still turn out juicy in the end.

Wear Protective Gear Such as Gloves and Goggles

Wear Protective Gear Such as Gloves and Goggles

It may feel a bit silly to get all geared up to cook a simple turkey, but we're going to go ahead and use the cliche phrase: better safe than sorry. The most exposed parts during cooking are most often your face and hands, so you'll want to protect those.


You should pick up a pair of heat-resistant and oil-resistant gloves, like ones designed specifically for frying or barbecuing. Goggles would also be a good investment since your vision could become severely impaired from oil burns. Don't skimp on protection!

Cook in a Safe and Open Space

Cook in a Safe and Open Space

You should have an abundant amount of open space around your fryer regardless of whether you're frying indoors or outdoors. If you're outdoors in particular, the safest place is either on a wide patio or on the grass.


It would also be a good idea to have a fire extinguisher on hand since oil fires can't be put out with water.

Looking for More Cooking Gear? Look No Further

Looking for More Cooking Gear? Look No Further

Believe it or not, there's more to life than just turkey. Here are some other gadgets that will help you discover and enjoy a wide variety of food.

Summary

There you have it - a list of the 7 best turkey fryers available online this year. Whether you decide to go with a propane or electric fryer, we'd recommend one that is stainless steel and is easy to clean. As long as you follow the instructions, you should be well on your way to being this year's Thanksgiving turkey hero.

Author: Shannon McNaught

Related Articles

  • Top 10 Best Knife Sharpeners to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Knife Sharpeners to Buy Online 2019
    There’s nothing worse than a dull knife when it comes to food preparation. You’ve got to hack and slash. And it can slip off the food and straight into your hand. Sharpening your knives will not only make them last longer, but also make your food preparation easier and safer.Today, many types of kitchen knife sharpeners are available on the market, ranging from electric sharpeners to whetstones. You don’t know which sharpener to choose? Keep reading. Our buying guide and list of popular products will help you narrow down your choices.
    Kitchen supplies
    31 views
  • Top 10 Best Stainless Steel Water Bottles around 500ml to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Stainless Steel Water Bottles around 500ml to Buy Online 2019
    As more people become environmentally conscious, many are turning to reusable water bottles to cut down on plastic waste. Particularly popular are stainless steel water bottles, which are great for keeping drinks cold or warm for up to twelve or more hours. This rise in popularity means that there’s now an abundance of stainless steel water bottles on the market, and when they more or less all look the same, how do you choose?But don’t worry, we’re here to help! Here is a handy guide that will help you compare features, design, and price so that you can make the best decision. If, at the end, you’re still a little lost, we’ve got ten of our favorites for you, too.
    Kitchen supplies
    32 views
  • Top 10 Best Apple Slicers to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Apple Slicers to Buy Online 2019
    Everyone is always looking for ways to make life easier. Peeled or not, apples are a delicious treat and can be eaten in many ways. But slicing them by hand can be time consuming and just full of hassle. So, it only makes sense that apple slicers are becoming a principal gadget in most American households.An apple slicer is no bulky, intricate, difficult machine. They’re typically small, convenient, and can be stored in your cupboard easily and safely. Whether you’re making just apple slices, apple crostini, or apple sauce, we’re going to help you find the right apple slicer for your purpose.
    Kitchen supplies
    23 views
  • Top 10 Best Tea Infusers to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Tea Infusers to Buy Online 2019
    With the crisp air, balding trees, and mall Santas slowly sneaking up onto us, it’s obvious that winter is right around the corner. And nothing screams winter quite like a hot cup of freshly brewed tea. While tea bags are convenient and easy, sometimes those slow, dark mornings beg for something with a little more flavor, a little more pizzazz.Something like loose-leaf. If you’re not accustomed to using loose-leaf though and don’t have the proper equipment, you might find yourself with mouthfuls of soggy tea leaves. If so, it might be time to consider investing in a tea infuser. We’ll help guide you to the perfect tea infuser, and if you’re still stuck, we’ve also got a list of our ten favorites that you can find online.
    Kitchen supplies
    32 views
  • 10 Best Hot Pot Cookers to Buy Online 2019
    10 Best Hot Pot Cookers to Buy Online 2019
    There’s nothing more comforting on a cold winter night than sitting around a table with your friends and family eating food that you all cooked together. And there’s no better way to do that than hot pot! From broths filled with mouth-numbing Sczechuan peppers to mild Japanese shabu shabu, hot pot is fun and easy to do at home–if you have the right materials.As the popularity of this traditionally Asian cooking style continues to rise in the West, so does the availability of tabletop heat sources and appropriately shaped pots. The only problem now is choosing! That’s why we’ve put together this quick guide to picking out the right hot pot cooker. If you still find yourself stuck after that, we’ve also included a list of our ten favorite hot pots to start your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    1,048 views
  • Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Food Storage Containers to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Food Storage Containers to Buy Online 2019
    Everybody knows that single-use plastics are bad for the environment, but in reality, all plastics are pretty terrible. So when it’s time to replace your food containers, instead of reaching for the first plastic container you see on the shelf, it might be a better idea to think about the wider impact your purchase will have.But even if you exclude plastics from your search, there are still so many options when it comes to food storage containers. So in this guide, we’ll go over the different things you should look out for when picking an eco-friendly food storage container. At the end, we’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites for you to start your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    165 views
  • Top 10 Best Shaved Ice Machines to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Shaved Ice Machines to Buy Online 2019
    Summer is right around the corner, and before you know it, the days will be getting hotter, and you’ll be looking for a way to cool off. While it can be fun to go out for a cool treat, it’s nice to also be able to make your own at home. Whether that’s slushies, snow cones, or frozen margaritas, a shaved ice machine is the best summer house guest.There are a ton of options available, but not all of them will suit your needs. In this guide, we’ll go over the factors to look out for when choosing the right shaved ice machine for you. At the end, we’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites to help you get started on your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    32 views
  • Top 10 Best Cotton Candy Machines to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Cotton Candy Machines to Buy Online 2019
    Some fair foods are pretty easy to replicate at home–funnel cakes, corn dogs, and candy apples, for example. But cotton candy, one of the most iconic and most fun to eat foods, is nearly impossible to make without a dedicated machine. Luckily, cotton candy machines are pretty easily accessible, even to those who just want to make some for themselves or the kids.But whether you’re looking to whip up some fluff for a small slumber party or a big fundraiser, you’re going to want a machine that works for your needs. In this guide, we’ll go over the different factors to consider when choosing a cotton candy machine. At the end, we’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites to help you get started on your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    32 views
  • Top 10 Best Portable Electric Stoves to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Portable Electric Stoves to Buy Online 2019
    Whether you’re cooking hot pot at the dinner table, short on stove space, or looking for a compact cooktop for your camper, it can be useful to have a portable electric stove. They’re convenient, easy to use, and safer than a gas stove. But there are a ton of options, and finding the right one can be a challenge.On top of how well the stove works objectively, you also need to consider how well it would fit into your lifestyle. In this guide, we’ll talk about the factors you should consider when choosing a portable electric stove. At the end, we’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites to help you get started on your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    42 views
  • Top 10 Best Japanese Soup and Food Jars to Buy Online 2019 - Tried and True!
    Top 10 Best Japanese Soup and Food Jars to Buy Online 2019 - Tried and True!
    Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and kakaku.com) for the best soup and food jars. We picked out the 10 most popular products and tested them for the following:1. Heat Retention2. Cold Retention3. Washability (Is it easy to clean?)4. Weight5. Tightness (Is it spill-proof?)This is how we hand-picked the most exceptional Japanese soup and food jars.
    Kitchen supplies
    81 views
  • Popular Articles

  • 10 Best Hot Pot Cookers to Buy Online 2019
    10 Best Hot Pot Cookers to Buy Online 2019
    There’s nothing more comforting on a cold winter night than sitting around a table with your friends and family eating food that you all cooked together. And there’s no better way to do that than hot pot! From broths filled with mouth-numbing Sczechuan peppers to mild Japanese shabu shabu, hot pot is fun and easy to do at home–if you have the right materials.As the popularity of this traditionally Asian cooking style continues to rise in the West, so does the availability of tabletop heat sources and appropriately shaped pots. The only problem now is choosing! That’s why we’ve put together this quick guide to picking out the right hot pot cooker. If you still find yourself stuck after that, we’ve also included a list of our ten favorite hot pots to start your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    1,048 views
  • Top 10 Best Reusable Ice Cubes to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Reusable Ice Cubes to Buy Online 2019
    It’s summer, it’s hot, and you just want a cold drink. But unless you’re just drinking water, it’s hard to ignore the fact that your melting ice cubes water down your drinks and change the flavor! Luckily, there are reusable ice cubes that don’t melt away and can be used over and over. But there are also a ton of different options, and it can be hard to figure out which one is the best for you.That’s where we come in! In this guide, we’ll run through a few things you should consider when choosing reusable ice cubes, and if you still find yourself stuck, we’ve also got ten of our favorites to help make the decision a little easier.
    Kitchen supplies
    386 views
  • Top 10 Best Japanese Soup and Food Jars to Buy Online 2019 - Tried and True!
    Top 10 Best Japanese Soup and Food Jars to Buy Online 2019 - Tried and True!
    Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and kakaku.com) for the best soup and food jars. We picked out the 10 most popular products and tested them for the following:1. Heat Retention2. Cold Retention3. Washability (Is it easy to clean?)4. Weight5. Tightness (Is it spill-proof?)This is how we hand-picked the most exceptional Japanese soup and food jars.
    Kitchen supplies
    81 views
  • Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Food Storage Containers to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Food Storage Containers to Buy Online 2019
    Everybody knows that single-use plastics are bad for the environment, but in reality, all plastics are pretty terrible. So when it’s time to replace your food containers, instead of reaching for the first plastic container you see on the shelf, it might be a better idea to think about the wider impact your purchase will have.But even if you exclude plastics from your search, there are still so many options when it comes to food storage containers. So in this guide, we’ll go over the different things you should look out for when picking an eco-friendly food storage container. At the end, we’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites for you to start your search.
    Kitchen supplies
    165 views
  • Top 10 Best Stainless Steel Water Bottles around 500ml to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Stainless Steel Water Bottles around 500ml to Buy Online 2019
    As more people become environmentally conscious, many are turning to reusable water bottles to cut down on plastic waste. Particularly popular are stainless steel water bottles, which are great for keeping drinks cold or warm for up to twelve or more hours. This rise in popularity means that there’s now an abundance of stainless steel water bottles on the market, and when they more or less all look the same, how do you choose?But don’t worry, we’re here to help! Here is a handy guide that will help you compare features, design, and price so that you can make the best decision. If, at the end, you’re still a little lost, we’ve got ten of our favorites for you, too.
    Kitchen supplies
    32 views
  • Top 7 Best Silicone Stretch Lids to Buy Online 2019
    Top 7 Best Silicone Stretch Lids to Buy Online 2019
    We’ve all heard by now that plastic isn’t the best thing to be using, especially in the kitchen. But food can’t just be exposed all the time, so we’ve searched the internet to uncover the best silicone stretch lids available.After poring over descriptions and reviews, we’ve come to the conclusion that the best lids are made from food safe materials, stretch to fit the size and shape of your containers, and meet your organizational needs. Keeping these things in mind, we’ve selected some of the best silicone stretch lids available online.
    Kitchen supplies
    50 views
  • Top 10 Best Kitchen Utensil Holders to Buy Online 2019
    Top 10 Best Kitchen Utensil Holders to Buy Online 2019
    From spatulas to slotted spoons, tongs to prongs, if you’re an avid cook, you may find yourself with more utensils than you know what to do with. What you need, then, is a way to store them all that will make them easy to find, easy to access, and maybe even easy to show off. In this guide, we’ll go over the different types of kitchen utensil holders and how to make sense of the variations, so that you can choose the best one for you. If you find yourself still a little lost, we’ve also got a list of ten of our favorites for inspiration.
    Kitchen supplies
    37 views
  • Popular Item Lists

    Search by Category