Maybelline Lashionista Review - mybest

Our editors purchased Maybelline’s Lashionista and put it to the test. We wanted to see if it would add volume, length, and curl without clumping, if it was easy to remove, and if it was smudge-proof.

We also checked how easy it was to apply. While a professional makeup artist might be able to get an amazing look out of a difficult product, we like things that are quick and simple. This is what we learned during testing.
  • Last updated: 10-27-2019
  • 1,680 views
Table of Contents

What are the Lashionista’s Selling Points?

Maybelline’s Lashionista is a tubing mascara, meaning it comes off with hot water. There’s a bunch of little fiber strands in the formula. They adhere onto your lashes, adding volume and length. The brush is also supposed to separate out each individual lash so you’re clump free.
The Lashionista went through a renewal in 2018. The fiber used is now 15% lighter, meaning the product weighs less on your lashes so they stay curled and perky for longer. The brush is also slimmer and more curved than before. It’s meant to fit the shape of your eye better so you can get at those hard-to-reach corners.

Putting Maybelline’s Lashionista to the Test

Putting Maybelline’s Lashionista to the Test
We had a group of editors put Maybelline’s Lashionista to the test. Specifically, we were looking for the following five factors.
Test ①: Application
Test ②: Finish
Test ③: Smudge Resistance
Test ④: Curl
Test ⑤: Removability

Test ①: Application

We favor cosmetics that are easy to use.

Thick Formula Makes Delicate Work Difficult

Thick Formula Makes Delicate Work Difficult
We chose to test out the black mascara (there’s also brown). We wanted to check for any flaking during application, so we went all out and applied 10 coats to both our top and bottom lashes.
None of the fiber strands got into our eyes. Because the product was so thick–thanks to the fibers–we didn’t want to bring the brush too close to our eyes for fear of fallout. So despite how small the brush was, it was hard for us to reach our bottom lashes and the inner corners of our eyes.

Test ②: Finish

We were looking for a sleek finish, where our lashes were longer and thicker but still somewhat natural.

Ten Coats Will Give You Both Volume and Length…

Ten Coats Will Give You Both Volume and Length…
We applied mascara onto the lashes of our left eye (actually, our right, your left). The eye on the right is unadorned–just in case you couldn’t tell.
During application, we made sure to follow the directions listed on Maybelline’s official site. That is, we

  • Started applying from the root of the lashes, swiftly pulling the brush towards the ends.

  • Applied in one smooth motion, without wiggling the brush.

We’d say our lashes were about 1.5 times longer. Ten coats will certainly give you volume and length, though we will admit that our lashes didn’t change too much with just one or two.

…Just be Prepared for Some Serious Clumping

…Just be Prepared for Some Serious Clumping
You could apply just a few coats and settle for a natural but more subtle look. Or you could apply ten coats and attain both volume and length–but not a sleek finish. Our lashes stuck together in clumps and stray fibers poked out in odd directions, looking like split ends.
The brush also picks up a lot of product. We recommend wiping the excess off on a tissue before applying.

Test ③: Smudge Resistance

We put the mascara through an eight-hour wear test.

Quick-Drying But…

Quick-Drying But…
This is what we looked like five minutes after application. The mascara had already dried and didn’t smear when we touched it (lightly).

…Fades with Oil and Flakes off Throughout the Day

…Fades with Oil and Flakes off Throughout the Day
And this is what we looked like eight hours after application. There were black smudges under our eyes, and the mascara we applied onto our bottom lashes had disappeared.
None of us had been sweating or crying throughout the day, so the mascara likely 1) is weak to oil and 2) flakes off during the day. Those black smudges are actually little specks of mascara. Luckily, none of those specks smeared much (which would have resulted in the classic panda look), but this isn’t a mascara we’d want to wear for long periods of time.

Test ④: Curl

We also checked how perky our lashes were after eight hours.

Light Enough that Lashes Don’t Droop

Light Enough that Lashes Don’t Droop
This is what our lashes looked like right after application (from a slightly different angle). Despite all the fibers in the formula, the mascara wasn’t so heavy that it caused our lashes to droop.

But Solid Enough that Lashes Stay Curled over the Course of a Day

But Solid Enough that Lashes Stay Curled over the Course of a Day
And this is what it looked like after eight hours. Our lashes were just as curly as they’d been at the beginning of the day. Keep in mind that we neither used a primer nor a top coat during testing.
And even if humidity or sweat were to straighten out your lashes, you could probably just take a curler to them and they’d perk right back up again.

Test ⑤: Removability

This refers to how easy the mascara is to wash off at the end of the day.

Comes off in About 30 Seconds with Warm Water

Comes off in About 30 Seconds with Warm Water
A shower’s about 40℃ (104℉). We soaked a cotton pad with water that we’d warmed up to 40℃ and held it to our lashes. Immediately, the mascara started coming off in big flakes.
We repeated this three times (meaning we used three different cotton squares) before all the mascara on one set of lashes came off. Both eyes took six cotton pads and a total of only 30 seconds. That’s pretty fast.

The Final Verdict: Comes out to a Nice Finish if You Put in the Effort. Worth It if It Aligns with Your Priorities

The Final Verdict: Comes out to a Nice Finish if You Put in the Effort. Worth It if It Aligns with Your Priorities
There’s plenty of fibers in here, and if you apply about ten coats, you’ll get obvious volume and length. Apply a bit less, and you get a subtler look that still brings out your eyes.
However, the mascara smears clumps and smears like nobody’s business. You’ll have to go the extra mile during application, wiping off excess on a tissue, separating out your lashes with a spoolie, and applying a smudge-proof top coat.
Still, it could hold a curl and came off easily at the end of the day. If you’re willing to put in the extra effort when applying, then the Lashionista may be worth it.

Interested in Japanese and Korean Mascaras? We’ve Ranked 38 of Them

Interested in Japanese and Korean Mascaras? We’ve Ranked 38 of Them
Tubing, waterproof, lengthening, volumizing–we’ve tried them all. If you find that the Lashionista doesn’t appeal to you after all, feel free to look below for other options.

Summary

We put Maybelline’s Lashionista to the test. It did some things well–it volumized and lengthened, kept a curl, came off easily. As long as you are careful during application and apply a smudge-proof top coat, it’s worth using.

Related Articles

  • Top 10 Best Lip Balms in 2021 (Burt's Bees, DHC, and More)
    Top 10 Best Lip Balms in 2021 (Burt's Bees, DHC, and More)
    If you’re constantly ripping little shreds of skin from your lips, you know you need lip balm. But every lip balm has its own features and benefits: it can be medicated, tinted, scented, or flavored; it can provide UV protection; it can be made up of anything from natural beeswax to petroleum and mineral oils.Choosing the right lip balm can be an overwhelming task. That’s why we’ve done it for you. We have compiled a list of 10 popular lip balms that are truly effective, so you can finally say goodbye to dry, chapped, and sore lips.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,127 views
  • Top 10 Best Setting Powders for Oily Skin in 2021 (Neutrogena, Maybelline, and More)
    Top 10 Best Setting Powders for Oily Skin in 2021 (Neutrogena, Maybelline, and More)
    The use of a good setting powder is non-negotiable in your makeup regime, especially if you are makeup enthusiast. It is the best way to keep your makeup in place, no matter where you are or what you do! However, given the plethora of options available online, how can you know which product actually works for your oily skin? Before you scour through online shopping sites to find the best setting powder for your oily skin, read our buying guide below to understand how to determine the best product for you. Also, have a look at our list of 10 incredible setting powders that have earned our praise. Sacha Cosmetics' setting powder was our favorite since it helps control oil to leave your skin shine-free. Scroll down for some more suggestions! 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,194 views
  • Top 10 Best Organic Aloe Vera Gels in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Top 10 Best Organic Aloe Vera Gels in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Get sunburns or acne breakouts? Aloe vera gels can help you soothe and heal them in no time! Aloe vera gels can deliver long-lasting moisture to your skin and hair, keeping them healthy. But not all gels are concentrated and packed with minerals, enzymes, and vitamins naturally occurring in aloe vera. Some are actually diluted with water or contain many additives. So when you're choosing a product, consider factors such as the processing method, the percentage of aloe vera in the product, and the color of the gel. Need further details? Scroll down to our top 10 best aloe vera gels and buying guide to get some helpful tips to assist you in choosing the right product! 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,101 views
  • Top 10 Best Korean Facial Cleansers in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Top 10 Best Korean Facial Cleansers in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Shocked and worried about the appearance of fine lines? Or perhaps you're annoyed with how much scrubbing you need to do to get that water-proof mascara off? Stress no more - Korean facial cleansers are here to save the day! Not only do they remove makeup effectively, leaving your face clean and smooth, but they also have the power to do so much more for the skin. They can even prevent signs of aging. Consider The Face Shop's Rice Water Bright Foaming Cleanser, which removes dead skin cells, hydrates, and soothes the skin all at the same time! We've picked out the best of the best Korean facial cleansers online and included a buying guide in case you're still unsure what this first step in the world-famous Korean skincare routine entails. Here's to great-looking skin! 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    4,561 views
  • Top 10 Best Korean Hand Creams in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Top 10 Best Korean Hand Creams in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    The Korean wave (also known as the Hallyu wave) is now a global phenomenon! We see it everywhere - Korean dramas, K-pop, and even in cosmetics and skincare. One of the most loved Korean products is hand creams! Just like our face, our hands need moisture and nourishment too. You use your hands every day for all kinds of activities, so why not pamper them? That's what inspired us to do our research and find the top 10 Korean hand creams beloved by many. Right on top of that list is Etude House’s Missing U Hand Cream - its lightweight formula hydrates your hands, and the packaging is adorable! Scroll down and check what other hand creams made it on the list. While you’re at it, read our buying guide to help you decide which one to choose!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    4,035 views
  • Top 10 Best Korean Cleansing Oils and Balms in 2021 (Etude House, Then I Met You, and More)
    Top 10 Best Korean Cleansing Oils and Balms in 2021 (Etude House, Then I Met You, and More)
    In search of a gentle yet effective cleanser? Try using Korean cleansing oil or balm! Usually, Korean cleansing products are formulated with gentle surfactants that can drive away impurities without stripping the skin of its natural moisture. They're further infused with various nourishing ingredients to slow down the aging process and keep your skin healthy and vibrant. That's why we researched the best of the best to recommend to you!One of the Korean cleansing products that is currently raved about is Heimish's All Clean Balm. It harnesses the power of natural ingredients such as coconut extract and citrus herb oil to help remove makeup and daily grime while brightening your overall complexion. We picked this as our top choice, and if you want to see our other favs, keep scrolling down! We also put together a buying guide to give you useful tips for choosing the right Korean cleansing oil or balm for your skin.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,514 views
  • Top 10 Best Pink Hair Dyes in 2021 (Arctic Fox, Lime Crime, and More)
    Top 10 Best Pink Hair Dyes in 2021 (Arctic Fox, Lime Crime, and More)
    If you want to dye your hair into a fun color that will help you stand out, try pink! There are many shades for you to test out, from soft, tender pastel pink to vibrant hot pink. There are even some that glow under blacklight!For more detail about what shade would best suit your complexion, take a look at our buying guide. First, we have a list of the top 10 best pink hair dyes currently available online. Arctic Fox's Semi-Permanent Hair Color won first place on our list for its vivid pink color that lasted for a long time. The formula is moisturizing and won't turn your hair brittle or straw-like. Want more options? Keep reading!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    599 views
  • Top 10 Best Toe Separators in 2021 (Correct Toes, Vive Health, and More)
    Top 10 Best Toe Separators in 2021 (Correct Toes, Vive Health, and More)
    Whether you've just had a pedicure or you're trying to correct misaligned toes or a toe injury, then you might be in need of toe separators. With slits that keep your toes apart, this handy accessory is the perfect thing for making your toes feel extra loved. But it can be hard to sift through all the choices, so we looked for some of the most comfortable and functional ones and came up with a top 10 list for you. Topping it is Correct Toes' therapeutic spacers, which realign your toes using silicone. There are 9 more where that came from, so make sure you check out the rest of the products on our curated list as well as the buyer's guide we made to help you find your way around toe separators. 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    579 views
  • Top 10 Best Men's Shaving Kits in 2021 (Gillette, Remington, and More)
    Top 10 Best Men's Shaving Kits in 2021 (Gillette, Remington, and More)
    Looking to upgrade your shaving routine and minimize those nips and ingrown hairs? Perhaps you're interested in upgrading from a safety razor to a razor blade or looking for something that isn't a straight razor. Here are some of the best men's shaving kits on the market for you to try.For example, Gillette's Fusion Proshield 5 set comes with shaving cream and three blade refills, so you can expect many shaving sessions from the purchase. In addition, there are nine more shaving kits on the list that cater to different shaving styles. We've also included a buying guide to help you look for the most fitting shaving kit for your needs.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    238 views
  •  Top 10 Best Detangling Brushes in 2021 (Wet Brush, Tangle Teezer, and More)
    Top 10 Best Detangling Brushes in 2021 (Wet Brush, Tangle Teezer, and More)
    Do you struggle with combing through your hair without hurting or damaging it? Detangling brushes are great, especially if you have thick and curly hair that can get tangled and knotted easily. They are usually made with densely packed bristles that will eliminate knots without tugging or damaging your hair. With these, you will notice reduced breakage when you replace your regular hairbrush with this.With that being said, we went ahead and put together a list of our top 10 best detangling brushes to make brushing your hair more manageable. Our number one pick is Tangle Teezer's The Wet Detangler. We love that you can use it for all hair types and has a slim handle that's easy to grip. Keep scrolling to see what other brushes made it in our list, and go through the buying guide for tips on picking the right brush!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    237 views
  • Popular Articles

  • Top 23 Best Japanese Moisturizers in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, FANCL, and More)
    Top 23 Best Japanese Moisturizers in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, FANCL, and More)
    Last time, we talked about toners. Now, we move on to the next step in the Japanese skincare routine: moisturizers and face lotions. Face lotions are important–they are, if you remember, the lid that seals your toner in. And, just like in America, in Japan, we have our high-end and drugstore brands, our revolutionary products, and dupes.We thought it was high time someone separated the wheat from the chaff. That’s why we ordered the 23 most popular moisturizers and face lotions from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese moisturizers and face lotions. We also talk about the difference between lotion and cream at the very end of the article–be sure not to miss it.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    43,962 views
  • 8 Best Japanese Hair Dyes in 2021 - Tried and True! (Kao Liese, Palty, and More)
    8 Best Japanese Hair Dyes in 2021 - Tried and True! (Kao Liese, Palty, and More)
    Dyeing hair has been on-trend recently, but it can be expensive to do. Why not try an at-home kit instead of heading out to the salon? They're perfect for trying out different colors and getting a feel for dyeing hair in general. Japanese hair dyes, though formulated with dark, black Asian hair in mind, can also work great for other types of hair, but always make sure to conduct a patch test in case!To figure out what's best to use, we evaluated and tested eight of the most popular hair dyes found in drugstores in Japan and e-commerce sites. We tested them based on: three criteria: how vivid the color washow gentle the dye was on hairhow long the color lastedOur favorite was Liese Prettia Bubble Hair Color; check out why below!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    60,367 views
  • 10 Best Korean Night Creams in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Night Creams in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    If you're a K-beauty fanatic, you know that ingredients in Korean skincare can do a body good. When it comes to your nighttime routine, night creams are the perfect tool for ensuring a great beauty rest! That's why we went out of our way to research and compile a list of our absolute favorite Korean night creams.In our opinion, Neogen x Joan Kim VitaDuo Day and Night Cream is among the great Korean skincare products that provide great hydrating and moisturizing effects. Aside from being effective, it's also very innovative as it contains two creams - intensive day cream and night cream - in one container. Check out what more skincare products are a good addition to your night skincare routine! And if you're still full of questions, check out our buying guide with tips from aesthetician Devan Jesmer.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    23,948 views
  • 10 Best Korean Serums in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Serums in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    Want to make your skin glow? Korean serums are mild, lightweight, and contain a high concentration of active ingredients that can help all skin types. Some common skin-nourishing ingredients are ginseng, green tea, and aloe vera. Korean skincare also utilizes more unique ingredients, like snail mucin, placenta, and propolis! Check out our buying guide, which we prepared with the help of aesthetician Devan Jesmer, where you'll find all the necessary information regarding Korean serums, and our top 10 highly recommended products. Innisfree's Green Tea Seed Serum is our top-ranking product because it absorbs quickly, soothes irritated skin, and prevents signs of aging. If you want to know more, don't forget to check out the rest products on our list!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    19,708 views
  • 10 Best Japanese Body Washes in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Clover, and More)
    10 Best Japanese Body Washes in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Clover, and More)
    It can be hard to choose a good body wash when you have to worry about parabens, sensitive skin, oily skin, dry skin, and more. That's why we scoured Japanese e-commerce sites like Amazon, Rakuten, and Kakaku.com to find the best body washes available online. Then we purchased some of the most popular products and tested them for the following:Cleansing powerMoisturizing powerQuality of ingredientsFoam densityWe then compiled everything we learned into a buying guide about and list of the 10 of the best Japanese body washes available online.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    22,599 views
  • Top 26 Best Japanese Toners in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Fancl, and More)
    Top 26 Best Japanese Toners in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Fancl, and More)
    The Japanese skincare routine has quite a few steps. There’s cleansing; then the first step after cleansing is toning. To help you ease into Japanese skincare, we ordered the 26 most popular toners from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a specialist and had her compare the following:1. Application (How It Feels on Skin)2. HydrationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese toners. We also consulted our specialist about skincare–for example, we asked about how to properly put on toner and the order in which we should apply toner, lotion, and essences. We share all this information at the end of the article, so stay tuned.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    31,258 views
  • shu uemura Skin Purifier Anti/Oxi+ Cleansing Oil Review - mybest
    shu uemura Skin Purifier Anti/Oxi+ Cleansing Oil Review - mybest
    shu uemura’s Anti/Oxi+ Cleansing Oil is supposed to do more than remove makeup. It’s a time-rewinder, blemish buster, skin hydrator, mood lifter. That’s a lot to ask from one little green bottle.So this time around, our editors purchased this magical cleansing oil and put it to the test. We looked at whether the formula could pack a lot of cleansing power and still leave skin smooth and supple. We also inspected the ingredients list. This is everything we learned.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    967 views
  • Popular Expert Picks

    Search by Category