Maybelline Lashionista Review - mybest

Our editors purchased Maybelline’s Lashionista and put it to the test. We wanted to see if it would add volume, length, and curl without clumping, if it was easy to remove, and if it was smudge-proof.

We also checked how easy it was to apply. While a professional makeup artist might be able to get an amazing look out of a difficult product, we like things that are quick and simple. This is what we learned during testing.
  • Last updated: 10-27-2019
  • 1,555 views
Table of Contents

What are the Lashionista’s Selling Points?

Maybelline’s Lashionista is a tubing mascara, meaning it comes off with hot water. There’s a bunch of little fiber strands in the formula. They adhere onto your lashes, adding volume and length. The brush is also supposed to separate out each individual lash so you’re clump free.
The Lashionista went through a renewal in 2018. The fiber used is now 15% lighter, meaning the product weighs less on your lashes so they stay curled and perky for longer. The brush is also slimmer and more curved than before. It’s meant to fit the shape of your eye better so you can get at those hard-to-reach corners.

Putting Maybelline’s Lashionista to the Test

Putting Maybelline’s Lashionista to the Test
We had a group of editors put Maybelline’s Lashionista to the test. Specifically, we were looking for the following five factors.
Test ①: Application
Test ②: Finish
Test ③: Smudge Resistance
Test ④: Curl
Test ⑤: Removability

Test ①: Application

We favor cosmetics that are easy to use.

Thick Formula Makes Delicate Work Difficult

Thick Formula Makes Delicate Work Difficult
We chose to test out the black mascara (there’s also brown). We wanted to check for any flaking during application, so we went all out and applied 10 coats to both our top and bottom lashes.
None of the fiber strands got into our eyes. Because the product was so thick–thanks to the fibers–we didn’t want to bring the brush too close to our eyes for fear of fallout. So despite how small the brush was, it was hard for us to reach our bottom lashes and the inner corners of our eyes.

Test ②: Finish

We were looking for a sleek finish, where our lashes were longer and thicker but still somewhat natural.

Ten Coats Will Give You Both Volume and Length…

Ten Coats Will Give You Both Volume and Length…
We applied mascara onto the lashes of our left eye (actually, our right, your left). The eye on the right is unadorned–just in case you couldn’t tell.
During application, we made sure to follow the directions listed on Maybelline’s official site. That is, we

  • Started applying from the root of the lashes, swiftly pulling the brush towards the ends.

  • Applied in one smooth motion, without wiggling the brush.

We’d say our lashes were about 1.5 times longer. Ten coats will certainly give you volume and length, though we will admit that our lashes didn’t change too much with just one or two.

…Just be Prepared for Some Serious Clumping

…Just be Prepared for Some Serious Clumping
You could apply just a few coats and settle for a natural but more subtle look. Or you could apply ten coats and attain both volume and length–but not a sleek finish. Our lashes stuck together in clumps and stray fibers poked out in odd directions, looking like split ends.
The brush also picks up a lot of product. We recommend wiping the excess off on a tissue before applying.

Test ③: Smudge Resistance

We put the mascara through an eight-hour wear test.

Quick-Drying But…

Quick-Drying But…
This is what we looked like five minutes after application. The mascara had already dried and didn’t smear when we touched it (lightly).

…Fades with Oil and Flakes off Throughout the Day

…Fades with Oil and Flakes off Throughout the Day
And this is what we looked like eight hours after application. There were black smudges under our eyes, and the mascara we applied onto our bottom lashes had disappeared.
None of us had been sweating or crying throughout the day, so the mascara likely 1) is weak to oil and 2) flakes off during the day. Those black smudges are actually little specks of mascara. Luckily, none of those specks smeared much (which would have resulted in the classic panda look), but this isn’t a mascara we’d want to wear for long periods of time.

Test ④: Curl

We also checked how perky our lashes were after eight hours.

Light Enough that Lashes Don’t Droop

Light Enough that Lashes Don’t Droop
This is what our lashes looked like right after application (from a slightly different angle). Despite all the fibers in the formula, the mascara wasn’t so heavy that it caused our lashes to droop.

But Solid Enough that Lashes Stay Curled over the Course of a Day

But Solid Enough that Lashes Stay Curled over the Course of a Day
And this is what it looked like after eight hours. Our lashes were just as curly as they’d been at the beginning of the day. Keep in mind that we neither used a primer nor a top coat during testing.
And even if humidity or sweat were to straighten out your lashes, you could probably just take a curler to them and they’d perk right back up again.

Test ⑤: Removability

This refers to how easy the mascara is to wash off at the end of the day.

Comes off in About 30 Seconds with Warm Water

Comes off in About 30 Seconds with Warm Water
A shower’s about 40℃ (104℉). We soaked a cotton pad with water that we’d warmed up to 40℃ and held it to our lashes. Immediately, the mascara started coming off in big flakes.
We repeated this three times (meaning we used three different cotton squares) before all the mascara on one set of lashes came off. Both eyes took six cotton pads and a total of only 30 seconds. That’s pretty fast.

The Final Verdict: Comes out to a Nice Finish if You Put in the Effort. Worth It if It Aligns with Your Priorities

The Final Verdict: Comes out to a Nice Finish if You Put in the Effort. Worth It if It Aligns with Your Priorities
There’s plenty of fibers in here, and if you apply about ten coats, you’ll get obvious volume and length. Apply a bit less, and you get a subtler look that still brings out your eyes.
However, the mascara smears clumps and smears like nobody’s business. You’ll have to go the extra mile during application, wiping off excess on a tissue, separating out your lashes with a spoolie, and applying a smudge-proof top coat.
Still, it could hold a curl and came off easily at the end of the day. If you’re willing to put in the extra effort when applying, then the Lashionista may be worth it.

Interested in Japanese and Korean Mascaras? We’ve Ranked 38 of Them

Interested in Japanese and Korean Mascaras? We’ve Ranked 38 of Them
Tubing, waterproof, lengthening, volumizing–we’ve tried them all. If you find that the Lashionista doesn’t appeal to you after all, feel free to look below for other options.

Summary

We put Maybelline’s Lashionista to the test. It did some things well–it volumized and lengthened, kept a curl, came off easily. As long as you are careful during application and apply a smudge-proof top coat, it’s worth using.

Related Articles

  • Top 23 Best Japanese Whitening Serums in 2021 - Tried and True! (Haku, SK-II, and More)
    Top 23 Best Japanese Whitening Serums in 2021 - Tried and True! (Haku, SK-II, and More)
    It’s a buzzword in Japan: translucence. It’s similar to Korea’s glass skin–skin so pure that it’s nearly transparent, resembling layers of frosted glass. In the Western world, think "glow" or "dewy finish." In order to respond to that aesthetic, cosmetic companies–both drugstore and high-end–here have been coming out with scores of whitening serums, essences, and ampoules.As always, it’s difficult to tell what kind of skincare is effective and what isn’t. That’s why, this time around, we ordered the 24 most popular whitening serums from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese whitening serums, essences, and ampoules. See why we picked Chifure's Whitening Essence VC as our top choice and more!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    43,140 views
  • Top 10 Best Scalp Exfoliators in 2021 (Nexxus, Head and Shoulders, and More)
    Top 10 Best Scalp Exfoliators in 2021 (Nexxus, Head and Shoulders, and More)
    Have you been struggling with dandruff? Or maybe you just feel like your head needs a little more TLC. Just like with the rest of your skin, your scalp can benefit from a deep, exfoliating treatment. Scalp exfoliators come in all shapes or sizes but are often made from gritty ingredients like salt or with exfoliating acids. To save you time and trouble, we've done all the research and curated a list of the top 10 best scalp exfoliators this year! Our favorite is Briogeo's Scalp Revival. Their blend of vegetable-based microbeads and charcoal provides a safe and gentle exfoliant for any type of skin. Keep on reading for our other favorites, a buying guide, and more. 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,774 views
  • Maybelline Snapscara Review
    Maybelline Snapscara Review
    Maybelline Snapscara is tubing mascara, meaning it comes off with water. Getting good tubing mascara is one of the best things you can do for your lashes (other than putting nothing on them at all, but we aren’t giving up our smokey eyes). Still, you can’t help but wonder whether the mascara will flake. If it’ll clump. If it’ll even volumize or elongate your lashes at all.Our editing department purchased Maybelline’s Snapscara and sought to answer the above questions. This is what we learned during testing.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    2,572 views
  • Heroine Make Advanced Film Mascara Review
    Heroine Make Advanced Film Mascara Review
    It’s almost like a formula: Japanese + eyelashes = Heroine Make. If you know anything about Japanese cosmetics, you’re no doubt familiar with the brand and their peacock-lashed characters, a mashup between Disney princesses and shojo manga heroines from the 90s.So this time around, our editing department purchased Heroine Make’s popular Long & Curl Mascara – Advanced Film. We checked for smudge-resistance, finish, and removability. We also made sure it was easy to apply. This is what we learned during testing.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    2,252 views
  • Top 10 Best Facial Steamers in 2021
    Top 10 Best Facial Steamers in 2021
    Clogged pores are one of the main reasons behind acne breakouts and blackheads. They're also what inspires people to use steamers to deep-clean their faces. The powerful steam emitted by a facial steamer can open your skin's pores that are clogged by oil, impurities, and dead skin cells. This prepares your skin for the extraction of the acne-causing comedones (blackheads and whiteheads) and reduces further breakouts. This article takes you through finding the best facial steamers from amongst the online marketplaces and offers a comprehensive guide to help you find the best choice for you.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,492 views
  • Top 10 Best Dreadlock Shampoos in 2021 (Neutrogena, Aveeno, and More)
    Top 10 Best Dreadlock Shampoos in 2021 (Neutrogena, Aveeno, and More)
    Taking care of dreadlocks can be more challenging than other hair types since you may have to deal with lint, dirt, and residue buildup. So to keep your dreads clean and healthy, you need a strong cleansing shampoo that can clear out impurities while providing moisture to your locks. A shampoo designed for dreadlocks should also be lightweight to avoid weighing your hair down or making it feel greasy.Among various products online, Maple Holistics' Tea Tree Special Formula Shampoo took the top prize in our list of favorites! This shampoo is formulated with essential oils like tea tree, rosemary, and lavender that can help rejuvenate and strengthen your locks. Plus, it's hypoallergenic and suitable for all hair types! Continue reading to find out what other dreadlock shampoos made the cut in our top 10 list and to find tips for choosing the right product for yourself! 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,346 views
  • Top 21 Best Japanese Shampoos for Color-Treated Hair in 2021
    Top 21 Best Japanese Shampoos for Color-Treated Hair in 2021
    Whether you dye your hair at home or go to a salon, it takes time, effort, and money to get the perfect color. You want it to last as long as possible, right? But did you know the right shampoo can keep your color from fading too fast? There are so many good Japanese shampoos for color-treated hair, like Belluga, DHC, and Napla. So how can you choose the best?You don't have to be a beautician! Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites such as Amazon, Rakuten, and Yahoo! Shopping for the best Japanese shampoos for color-treated hair available online. We then picked out the most popular products and tested them.With the advice of our expert, we focused on five things:Does it have good ingredients?How well does it wash?How well does it protect hair color?Does it leave hair smooth?Is it nice to use?We then ranked the products and put what we learned into a buying guide to help you choose the best Japanese shampoo for color-treated hair available online.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    285 views
  • Top 10 Best Vegan Sunscreens in 2021 (Supergoop!, Coola, and More)
    Top 10 Best Vegan Sunscreens in 2021 (Supergoop!, Coola, and More)
    Sunscreens might contain animal or animal-derived ingredients such as collagen and elastin. So, for those who follow a vegan lifestyle, you might want to look specifically for sunscreens that are labeled as vegan. Since vegan sunscreens come in different consistencies and levels of sun protection factor, though, it might be tough to know which product is right for you. If you're looking for some suggestions, check out our list of favorites! Supergoop's Unseen Sunscreen won our grand prize thanks to its lightweight and antioxidant-rich formula that's highly effective in defending your skin against the damages of UV rays. Read on to know about nine other great options and take a look at our buying guide at the end for some tips in choosing a vegan sunscreen. 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    222 views
  • Top 10 Best CC Creams for Dark Skin in 2021 (Clinique, Hey Honey, and More)
    Top 10 Best CC Creams for Dark Skin in 2021 (Clinique, Hey Honey, and More)
    CC cream, or color-correcting cream, is a foundation alternative that helps conceal imperfections and even out your complexion. It can even prevent and treat hyperpigmentation, a significant problem for dark skin. CC cream is often formulated with many antioxidants and moisturizers to keep your skin healthy, too! But CC cream may not be as widely available for darker skin tones, so where do you start?To help you out with your search, we've narrowed down the 10 best CC creams that are highly recommended by reviewers with dark skin. Our top choice was Juice Beauty's Stem Cellular CC Cream for its moisturizing and anti-aging properties. Read on for nine other great options, and check out our buying guide at the end as well for some tips in choosing the best CC cream for dark skin. 
    Cosmetics and skincare
    116 views
  • Top 10 Best Products for Body Acne in 2021 (Proactiv, Mighty Patch, and More)
    Top 10 Best Products for Body Acne in 2021 (Proactiv, Mighty Patch, and More)
    Have you started breaking out on your back, shoulders, and chest? Or want to dress cooler for the summer but are embarrassed because of the way your skin looks? Luckily, there are plenty of products out there for body acne. From preventative exfoliators to leave-on treatments, you can use one or more of these items to help clear up your body acne. Our top 10 list gives you a preview of the various types of products you can use. We chose Proactiv's Deep Cleansing Acne Body Wash for its medicated and exfoliating ingredients, including salicylic acid. Be sure to also check out our buying guide, which has information on how to choose a product for body acne and when it's best to make an appointment with a dermatologist. Keep reading to find out more!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    159 views
  • Popular Articles

  • 10 Best Korean Night Creams in 2021 (Etude House, Innisfree, and More)
    10 Best Korean Night Creams in 2021 (Etude House, Innisfree, and More)
    If you're a K-beauty fanatic, you know that ingredients in Korean skincare can do a body good. When it comes to your nighttime routine, night creams are the perfect tool for ensuring a great beauty rest! That's why we went out of our way to research and compile a list of our absolute favorite Korean night creams.In our opinion, Neogen x Joan Kim VitaDuo Day and Night Cream is among the great Korean skincare products that provide great hydrating and moisturizing effects. Aside from being effective, it's also very innovative as it contains two creams - intensive day cream and night cream - in one container. Check out what more skincare products are a good addition to your night skincare routine! And if you're still full of questions, check out our buying guide with tips from aesthetician Devan Jesmer.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    19,891 views
  • Top 23 Best Japanese Moisturizers in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, FANCL, and More)
    Top 23 Best Japanese Moisturizers in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, FANCL, and More)
    Last time, we talked about toners. Now, we move on to the next step in the Japanese skincare routine: moisturizers and face lotions. Face lotions are important–they are, if you remember, the lid that seals your toner in. And, just like in America, in Japan, we have our high-end and drugstore brands, our revolutionary products, and dupes.We thought it was high time someone separated the wheat from the chaff. That’s why we ordered the 23 most popular moisturizers and face lotions from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese moisturizers and face lotions. We also talk about the difference between lotion and cream at the very end of the article–be sure not to miss it.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    40,589 views
  • 10 Best Japanese Body Washes in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Clover, and More)
    10 Best Japanese Body Washes in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Clover, and More)
    It can be hard to choose a good body wash when you have to worry about parabens, sensitive skin, oily skin, dry skin, and more. That's why we scoured Japanese e-commerce sites like Amazon, Rakuten, and Kakaku.com to find the best body washes available online. Then we purchased some of the most popular products and tested them for the following:Cleansing powerMoisturizing powerQuality of ingredientsFoam densityWe then compiled everything we learned into a buying guide about and list of the 10 of the best Japanese body washes available online.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    19,066 views
  • Top 26 Best Japanese Toners in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Fancl, and More)
    Top 26 Best Japanese Toners in 2021 - Tried and True! (Minon, Fancl, and More)
    The Japanese skincare routine has quite a few steps. There’s cleansing; then the first step after cleansing is toning. To help you ease into Japanese skincare, we ordered the 26 most popular toners from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a specialist and had her compare the following:1. Application (How It Feels on Skin)2. HydrationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese toners. We also consulted our specialist about skincare–for example, we asked about how to properly put on toner and the order in which we should apply toner, lotion, and essences. We share all this information at the end of the article, so stay tuned.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    28,193 views
  • Top 23 Best Japanese Whitening Serums in 2021 - Tried and True! (Haku, SK-II, and More)
    Top 23 Best Japanese Whitening Serums in 2021 - Tried and True! (Haku, SK-II, and More)
    It’s a buzzword in Japan: translucence. It’s similar to Korea’s glass skin–skin so pure that it’s nearly transparent, resembling layers of frosted glass. In the Western world, think "glow" or "dewy finish." In order to respond to that aesthetic, cosmetic companies–both drugstore and high-end–here have been coming out with scores of whitening serums, essences, and ampoules.As always, it’s difficult to tell what kind of skincare is effective and what isn’t. That’s why, this time around, we ordered the 24 most popular whitening serums from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese whitening serums, essences, and ampoules. See why we picked Chifure's Whitening Essence VC as our top choice and more!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    43,140 views
  • 10 Best Korean Serums in 2021 (Innisfree, Sulwahsoo, and More)
    10 Best Korean Serums in 2021 (Innisfree, Sulwahsoo, and More)
    Want to make your skin glow? Korean serums are mild, lightweight, and contain a high concentration of active ingredients that can help all skin types. Some common skin-nourishing ingredients are ginseng, green tea, and aloe vera. Korean skincare also utilizes more unique ingredients, like snail mucin, placenta, and propolis! Check out our buying guide, which we prepared with the help of aesthetician Devan Jesmer, where you'll find all the necessary information regarding Korean serums, and our top 10 highly recommended products. Innisfree's Green Tea Seed Serum is our top-ranking product because it absorbs quickly, soothes irritated skin, and prevents signs of aging. If you want to know more, don't forget to check out the rest products on our list!
    Cosmetics and skincare
    16,561 views
  • Top 19 Best Japanese Face Washes for Sensitive Skin to Buy Online 2021 - Tried and True!
    Top 19 Best Japanese Face Washes for Sensitive Skin to Buy Online 2021 - Tried and True!
    People with sensitive skin can agree on one thing: finding products suitable for your skin is time-consuming and at times painful. That's why our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites (such as @cosme, Amazon, and Rakuten) for the best face washes for sensitive skin. We then chose the 19 most popular products and tested them.We focused on three things: its cleansing power, its post-wash hydration level, and its ingredients. We then compiled everything we learned into a buying guide about and list of the best Japanese face washes for sensitive skin available online.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    2,888 views
  • Popular Expert Picks

    Search by Category