Heroine Make Waterproof Eyeliner Review

If you’ve stepped foot into a Japanese drugstore before, you’ve seen Heroine Make. They’re known as much for their cosmetics as they are for their twinkly-eyed heroines of yesteryear (who are oddly reminiscent of Roy Lichtenstein pop art). But are they popular because their products are good or is it just skillful advertising?

Our editing department purchased Heroine Make’s top-selling eyeliner to see if it was worth the hype. Specifically, we were looking at how easy it was to use, how well-pigmented it was, and how resistant to smudging. This is what we learned during testing.
  • Last updated: 10-24-2019
  • 992 views
Table of Contents
KISS ME Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP 1

KISS MEHeroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP

#001 Deep Black

$11.99

Tell Me More about Heroine Make's Eyeliners

Tell Me More about Heroine Make's Eyeliners

Heroine Make is one of the drugstore brands in Japan. Their eyeliner is known for being long-lasting--that is, water-, oil-, and overall smudge-resistant. And though this particular product is labeled waterproof, it's supposed to come off with warm water.


This eyeliner is well-pigmented and heavily accentuates the eyes. Available colors include Jet Black, Bitter Brown, Brown Black, and Navy Black (limited edition). The tip of the brush measures about 0.1 mm, making it perfect for precise work.


And despite the quality, Heroine Make's eyeliners are available at most drugstores in Japan for about 1,080 yen (a bit less than $10).

Putting Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner to the Test

Putting Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner to the Test
We had a group of editors put Heroine Make’s waterproof eyeliner to the test. Specifically, we were looking for the three following factors.
Test ①: Ease of Use
Test ②: Pigmentation
Test ③: Longevity

Test ①: Ease of Use

Because uneven eyeliner is everyone’s worst nightmare.

Just Flexible Enough. Easy to Draw Lines with, Both Thick and Thin

Just Flexible Enough. Easy to Draw Lines with, Both Thick and Thin
We thought the brush was just firm enough. It was stiff enough to give us a thin line when we needed it and soft enough to give us a thick line when we pressed down on it. There might be a bit of a learning curve if you’re used to pencil liners or are just getting into makeup, but it’s not a steep one.
We had no problem adding the flick at the end of a cat eye or applying onto our bottom lash line. Basically, it’s easy to use–you just need to figure out how much pressure you need and how you should angle the pen.

Test ②: Pigmentation

Because what’s the point of eyeliner that doesn’t show up?

Comes out to a Dense Jet Black

Comes out to a Dense Jet Black
We prepped our skin with a bit of foundation, then tested the eyeliner on it. As you can see, it came out dark and intense.
If the eyeliner’s still relatively new but the color looks a bit pale, there’s a good chance that the ink’s just not flowing right. Cap the eyeliner, give it a few good shakes, and that should fix the issue.

Intense Enough to Show up Under Eyeshadow

Intense Enough to Show up Under Eyeshadow
We’re all for applying eyeliner after your eyeshadow, but we did the following just to give you an idea of how intense this product is.
We tested the eyeliner out on our arm, then went over it with brown eyeshadow. While most liners would have their effect muddled by the powder, Heroine Make’s eyeliner remained just as crisp.

Test ③: Longevity

Because who likes reapplying makeup throughout the day?

Upper Lash Line Lasts All Day. While the Lower Lash Line Does Fade, It Doesn’t Smudge

Upper Lash Line Lasts All Day. While the Lower Lash Line Does Fade, It Doesn’t Smudge
We conducted a one-day wear test. We applied eyeliner to both our top and bottom lash lines; the picture above is what we looked like in the morning. We didn’t wear mascara so that if there were any smudging, we’d know who the culprit was.
The picture below is what we looked like at night. Our upper lash line stayed exactly the same, down to the flick at the end of the cateye.
Upper Lash Line Lasts All Day. While the Lower Lash Line Does Fade, It Doesn’t Smudge
However, our lower lash line faded a bit. We were careful not to touch our eyes during the day, so the liner was most likely washed away by tears or eyedrops. At the very least, we weren’t pandas. If you really want to nitpick, you can see a dark little smudge by the corner of our eye, but you wouldn’t notice it unless you were really looking.
When the eyeliner does fade, it doesn’t so much smudge as crumble off in flecks.

Doesn’t Wash Away with Water

Doesn’t Wash Away with Water
We misted some water onto our lids, then gently pressed down on our lash lines with a tissue. Almost no product came off. It proved itself sweat- and rain-resistant.
Doesn’t Wash Away with Water

The Final Verdict: Stays Crisp Throughout the Day. Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner Gets our Seal of Approval

The Final Verdict: Stays Crisp Throughout the Day. Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner Gets our Seal of Approval
We won’t say that Heroine Make’s waterproof eyeliner doesn’t fade at all, but it’ll stay crisp enough if all you’re doing is wearing it around town. And when it does come off, it’s not messy. It doesn’t smear; it flakes. We’d recommend it to people whose eyes water (either because they have allergies or spend all day laughing) or who regularly use eyedrops.
It comes out to an intense black, so it works if you’re looking for a dramatic look. However, the brush is easy to control, and you can easily get the eyeliner to come to a fine point–so it works if you want a more natural look as well. And all this for around 10 bucks.

Consider Other Color Variations, like Bitter Brown

KISS ME Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP 1

KISS MEHeroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP

#002 Bitter Brown

$10.98

The Jet Black might be Heroine Make's most popular variety, but their eyeliners are also available in colors like Bitter Brown and Brown Black. Choose black for a more intense look; choose brown to come off softer and more natural.


Heroine Make also periodically comes out with limited edition colors like Navy Black, so keep your eyes peeled for updates.

Curious about How Heroine Make’s Eyeliner Compares to Other Japanese Products?

Curious about How Heroine Make’s Eyeliner Compares to Other Japanese Products?
Our editors purchased and tested a whopping 45 different Japanese eyeliners–Heroine Make was just one of those. If you wanted to learn about all the different options you have or were curious about how Heroine Make stacks up, check out the article below.

Summary

We put Heroine Make’s waterproof eyeliner to the test. We were impressed by how intense and yet clean the finish was and how long it lasted. Overall, it’s a worthy purchase.

Related Articles

Popular Articles

  • Top 24 Best Japanese Whitening Serums, Essences, and Ampoules to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 24 Best Japanese Whitening Serums, Essences, and Ampoules to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    It’s a buzzword in Japan: translucence※1. It’s similar to Korea’s glass skin–skin so pure that it’s nearly transparent, resembling layers of frosted glass. In order to respond to that aesthetic, cosmetic companies–both drugstore and high-end–here have been coming out with scores of whitening※2 serums, essences, and ampoules※3.As always, it’s difficult to tell what kind of skincare is effective and what isn’t. That’s why, this time around, we ordered the 24 most popular whitening serums from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese whitening serums, essences, and ampoules.※1 透明感: translucence (lit. transparency; used to describe glass skin)※2 美白: whitening (in this article, that refers to the tamping down of hyperpigmentation and the production of melanin, thereby preventing freckles and blemishes)※3 美容液: serums, essences, and ampoules (more on how we translated that term below)
    Cosmetics and skincare
    19,775 views
  • Top 10 Best Japanese Hair Dyes to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 10 Best Japanese Hair Dyes to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Let’s get this straight–there’s no such thing as a “best” hair dye. Strictly speaking. Just like there’s no such thing as a “best” concealer or “best” mattress or “best” jacket because it all comes down to you. What kind of skin do you have? What kind of sleeping posture? Do you get cold easily?This time around, we ordered the 10 most popular hair dyes found in Japanese drugstores and on Japan’s e-commerce sites and compared the following:1. How vivid the color was2. How gentle on hair the dye was3. How long the color lastedHowever, we want you to keep in mind that the Japanese hair dyes we introduce were formulated with Japanese (naturally black, bleached Asian) hair in mind and are most effective on hair of a similar quality. If you’ve hair like that, great–you’ll probably find that it works better than your average box of CVS/Walgreens stuff. If not, though, results may be a bit unexpected.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    21,485 views
  • Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Razors to Buy Online 2020
    Top 10 Best Eco-Friendly Razors to Buy Online 2020
    It’s easy to see excessive plastic use when we go food shopping, but one area we might not pay as much attention to is in our shaving habits. Think about it: whether you use disposable razors where you throw away the whole thing or cartridge razors where the disposable blades are encased in plastic, if you shave a few times a week, all that waste can really add up.Luckily, all-metal, reusable razors are making a comeback, making it easy for you to get an eco-friendly shave. But it can be hard to figure out where to begin when you’re starting from scratch. In this guide, we’ll go over the major points to look for when buying an eco-friendly razor. At the end we’ve also got a list of our 10 favorites to get you started on your search.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    20,335 views
  • Top 24 Best Japanese Moisturizers and Face Lotions to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 24 Best Japanese Moisturizers and Face Lotions to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Last time, we talked about toners. Now, we move on to the next step in the Japanese skincare routine: moisturizers and face lotions※1. Face lotions are important–they are, if you remember, the lid that seals your toner in. And, just like in America, in Japan, we have our high-end and drugstore brands, our revolutionary products and dupes.We thought it was high time someone separated the wheat from the chaff. That’s why we ordered the 25 most popular moisturizers and face lotions from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese moisturizers and face lotions. We also talk about the difference between lotion and cream at the very end of the article–be sure not to miss it.※1 乳液: moisturizer / face lotion
    Cosmetics and skincare
    19,410 views
  • Top 18 Best Japanese Anti-Aging Serums, Essences, and Ampoules to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 18 Best Japanese Anti-Aging Serums, Essences, and Ampoules to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    We might not be able to prevent aging altogether, but we can still age gracefully. That feels like the consensus here in Japan, where anti-aging skincare is popular and constantly evolving. As time goes by, our skin undergoes certain changes–hormones are thrown out of balance, certain functions are dulled–and serums that you used once may no longer be as effective.So which serums a) target the signs of aging and b) will actually work for you? In order to answer that question, we ordered the 18 most popular anti-aging※1 serums※2 from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited a skincare specialist and had her compare the following:1. Hydration2. ApplicationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese anti-aging serums, essences, and ampoules.※1 エイジングケア: anti-aging (lit. aging care), which, in this article, refers to products meant to moisturize mature skin※2 美容液: serums, essences, and ampoules (all three are basically the same product, just with different concentration levels of active ingredients)
    Cosmetics and skincare
    13,239 views
  • Top 28 Best Japanese Toners to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 28 Best Japanese Toners to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    We don’t know when it started, but Japanese women are known–have been known for a while–for beautiful skin. And walking around Tokyo, you can’t help but think “where’s there’s smoke, there’s fire.” While there’s no one factor that makes one’s skin what it is, we’d hazard a guess and say skincare is important.The Japanese skincare routine has quite a few steps. There’s cleansing; then the first step after cleansing is toning. To help you ease into Japanese skincare, we ordered the 28 most popular toners※1 from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as Amazon, Rakuten, and @cosme) and tested them all. We also invited an specialist and had her compare the following:1. Application (How It Feels on Skin)2. HydrationThis is how we tested and found the most exceptional Japanese toners. We also consulted our specialist about skincare–for example, we asked about how to properly put on toner and the order in which we should apply toner, lotion, and essences. We share all this information at the end of the article, so stay tuned.※1 化粧水: tone
    Cosmetics and skincare
    9,353 views
  • Top 17 Best Japanese Face Creams to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Top 17 Best Japanese Face Creams to Buy Online 2020 - Tried and True!
    Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites (such as @cosme, Amazon, and Rakuten) for the best face creams. We then chose the 17 most popular products and tested them.We focused on three things: how moisturizing it was, how it felt to use, and what ingredients it contained. We then compiled everything we learned into a buying guide about and list of the best Japanese face creams available online.
    Cosmetics and skincare
    1,424 views
  • Popular Item Lists

    Search by Category