Heroine Make Waterproof Eyeliner Review

If you’ve stepped foot into a Japanese drugstore before, you’ve seen Heroine Make. They’re known as much for their cosmetics as they are for their twinkly-eyed heroines of yesteryear (who are oddly reminiscent of Roy Lichtenstein pop art). But are they popular because their products are good or is it just skillful advertising?

Our editing department purchased Heroine Make’s top-selling eyeliner to see if it was worth the hype. Specifically, we were looking at how easy it was to use, how well-pigmented it was, and how resistant to smudging. This is what we learned during testing.
  • Last updated: 10-24-2019
Table of Contents
KISS ME Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP 1

KISS MEHeroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP

#001 Deep Black

$11.99

Tell Me More about Heroine Make's Eyeliners

Tell Me More about Heroine Make's Eyeliners

Heroine Make is one of the drugstore brands in Japan. Their eyeliner is known for being long-lasting--that is, water-, oil-, and overall smudge-resistant. And though this particular product is labeled waterproof, it's supposed to come off with warm water.


This eyeliner is well-pigmented and heavily accentuates the eyes. Available colors include Jet Black, Bitter Brown, Brown Black, and Navy Black (limited edition). The tip of the brush measures about 0.1 mm, making it perfect for precise work.


And despite the quality, Heroine Make's eyeliners are available at most drugstores in Japan for about 1,080 yen (a bit less than $10).

Putting Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner to the Test

Putting Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner to the Test
We had a group of editors put Heroine Make’s waterproof eyeliner to the test. Specifically, we were looking for the three following factors.
Test ①: Ease of Use
Test ②: Pigmentation
Test ③: Longevity

Test ①: Ease of Use

Because uneven eyeliner is everyone’s worst nightmare.

Just Flexible Enough. Easy to Draw Lines with, Both Thick and Thin

Just Flexible Enough. Easy to Draw Lines with, Both Thick and Thin
We thought the brush was just firm enough. It was stiff enough to give us a thin line when we needed it and soft enough to give us a thick line when we pressed down on it. There might be a bit of a learning curve if you’re used to pencil liners or are just getting into makeup, but it’s not a steep one.
We had no problem adding the flick at the end of a cat eye or applying onto our bottom lash line. Basically, it’s easy to use–you just need to figure out how much pressure you need and how you should angle the pen.

Test ②: Pigmentation

Because what’s the point of eyeliner that doesn’t show up?

Comes out to a Dense Jet Black

Comes out to a Dense Jet Black
We prepped our skin with a bit of foundation, then tested the eyeliner on it. As you can see, it came out dark and intense.
If the eyeliner’s still relatively new but the color looks a bit pale, there’s a good chance that the ink’s just not flowing right. Cap the eyeliner, give it a few good shakes, and that should fix the issue.

Intense Enough to Show up Under Eyeshadow

Intense Enough to Show up Under Eyeshadow
We’re all for applying eyeliner after your eyeshadow, but we did the following just to give you an idea of how intense this product is.
We tested the eyeliner out on our arm, then went over it with brown eyeshadow. While most liners would have their effect muddled by the powder, Heroine Make’s eyeliner remained just as crisp.

Test ③: Longevity

Because who likes reapplying makeup throughout the day?

Upper Lash Line Lasts All Day. While the Lower Lash Line Does Fade, It Doesn’t Smudge

Upper Lash Line Lasts All Day. While the Lower Lash Line Does Fade, It Doesn’t Smudge
We conducted a one-day wear test. We applied eyeliner to both our top and bottom lash lines; the picture above is what we looked like in the morning. We didn’t wear mascara so that if there were any smudging, we’d know who the culprit was.
The picture below is what we looked like at night. Our upper lash line stayed exactly the same, down to the flick at the end of the cateye.
Upper Lash Line Lasts All Day. While the Lower Lash Line Does Fade, It Doesn’t Smudge
However, our lower lash line faded a bit. We were careful not to touch our eyes during the day, so the liner was most likely washed away by tears or eyedrops. At the very least, we weren’t pandas. If you really want to nitpick, you can see a dark little smudge by the corner of our eye, but you wouldn’t notice it unless you were really looking.
When the eyeliner does fade, it doesn’t so much smudge as crumble off in flecks.

Doesn’t Wash Away with Water

Doesn’t Wash Away with Water
We misted some water onto our lids, then gently pressed down on our lash lines with a tissue. Almost no product came off. It proved itself sweat- and rain-resistant.
Doesn’t Wash Away with Water

The Final Verdict: Stays Crisp Throughout the Day. Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner Gets our Seal of Approval

The Final Verdict: Stays Crisp Throughout the Day. Heroine Make’s Waterproof Eyeliner Gets our Seal of Approval
We won’t say that Heroine Make’s waterproof eyeliner doesn’t fade at all, but it’ll stay crisp enough if all you’re doing is wearing it around town. And when it does come off, it’s not messy. It doesn’t smear; it flakes. We’d recommend it to people whose eyes water (either because they have allergies or spend all day laughing) or who regularly use eyedrops.
It comes out to an intense black, so it works if you’re looking for a dramatic look. However, the brush is easy to control, and you can easily get the eyeliner to come to a fine point–so it works if you want a more natural look as well. And all this for around 10 bucks.

Consider Other Color Variations, like Bitter Brown

KISS ME Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP 1

KISS MEHeroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner WP

#002 Bitter Brown

$10.98

The Jet Black might be Heroine Make's most popular variety, but their eyeliners are also available in colors like Bitter Brown and Brown Black. Choose black for a more intense look; choose brown to come off softer and more natural.


Heroine Make also periodically comes out with limited edition colors like Navy Black, so keep your eyes peeled for updates.

Curious about How Heroine Make’s Eyeliner Compares to Other Japanese Products?

Curious about How Heroine Make’s Eyeliner Compares to Other Japanese Products?
Our editors purchased and tested a whopping 45 different Japanese eyeliners–Heroine Make was just one of those. If you wanted to learn about all the different options you have or were curious about how Heroine Make stacks up, check out the article below.

Summary

We put Heroine Make’s waterproof eyeliner to the test. We were impressed by how intense and yet clean the finish was and how long it lasted. Overall, it’s a worthy purchase.

Related Articles

  • 10 Best Natural Shampoos in 2022 (PURA D'OR, Alaffia, and More)
    10 Best Natural Shampoos in 2022 (PURA D'OR, Alaffia, and More)
    As consumers become more aware of what conventional shampoos contain, a growing number are shifting from chemical-filled products to plant-based alternatives. And so countless natural hair care products fill up store shelves. They promise great things, but can they really live up to what they claim?Don’t be mislead by catchy taglines or branding! To help you find that truly natural shampoo, we’ve compiled a list of popular product lines, including our absolute favorite, Majestic Pure Cosmeceuticals' Argan Oil Shampoo. We've also included a buying guide so that you know when to look for when you're browsing the shelves.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 10 Best Nude Lipsticks in 2021 (MAC, Marc Jacobs, and More)
    Top 10 Best Nude Lipsticks in 2021 (MAC, Marc Jacobs, and More)
    Nude lipstick is a classic look that never goes out of style. Although it's subtle, the right shade can work wonders, bringing out your natural features and giving you a healthy glow. You can wear nude lipstick on its own, mix it with other lipstick shades, top it with a gloss, and even use it as a blush if you're feeling creative. However, it's important to pick the right shade to suit your skin tone.  If you're not sure where to start, we've compiled a list of the top 10 best nude lipsticks as well as a buying guide that will walk you through how to choose your next go-to lipstick. For high pigmentation and long-lasting wear, our number one pick is Stila's Stay All Day Liquid Lipstick. The shade Patina is a gorgeous dusty rose that will enhance your natural lip color. Check out the rest of our picks below!
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 10 Best Nail Polishes in 2021
    Top 10 Best Nail Polishes in 2021
    Painted nails can enhance your outfit and make you look more attractive in other people's eyes. However, not everyone has the time and money to go to the salon frequently! Many people go for the DIY option instead. Nevertheless, choosing a suitable shade or a good nail polish is not an easy task, since there are a plethora of products currently available on the market from well-known brands such as Revlon, OPI, or essie. To help you quickly figure out which product to purchase, we browsed through reviews on Amazon as well as Sephora and compiled a list of top 10 best nail polishes. We've also included a buying guide to help you choose the right one for you.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 10 Best Non-Comedogenic Sunscreens in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Top 10 Best Non-Comedogenic Sunscreens in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    People with acne-prone skin or sensitive skin know very well that many sunscreens can cause breakouts or trigger allergic reactions, plus leave a greasy residue on the skin. Non-comedogenic formulas are the way to go since they won't clog your pores. You should also consider the SPF of the product to find one that can hold up against UVA and UVB rays.Get acquainted with Neutrogena's Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch Sunscreen, which has taken the top spot in our list of non-comedogenic sunscreens. It dries out in a matte, non-greasy finish, plus won't clog the pores. You can also choose from nine other sunscreens and look through the attached buying guide to help you pick the best non-comedogenic sunscreen for your skincare regime. 
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 10 Best Reef-Safe Sunscreens in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    10 Best Reef-Safe Sunscreens in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Swimming somewhere tropical? You'll need a reef-safe sunscreen. Statistics show that many sunscreens contain chemicals that can harm marine ecosystems, which include precious coral reefs. Luckily, rising awareness has given birth to reef-safe and reef-friendly sunscreens that won't hurt a thing!We've done a lot of research and pored through reviews to pick the 10 best reef-safe sunscreens for reefs and our skin. Blue Lizard's Sensitive Mineral Sunscreen took first place on our list as it can effectively shield your skin from harmful UV rays while protecting coral reefs. And after you've looked at our list, our buying guide will provide you with useful information on what needs to be considered when choosing non-toxic sunscreens with research backed by a dermatologist. 
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 10 Best Gel Sunscreens in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Top 10 Best Gel Sunscreens in 2021 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    If you're frustrated with the heavy sunscreen creams, then it's time to say hello to lightweight, fast-absorbing sunscreen gels. Sunscreen gels are transparent and tend to dry to a matte or satin finish, so you can say goodbye to greasiness! That's why we did our research to find 10 of the best gel sunscreens out there right now.Our top pick was the famous Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen. Along with being vegan and cruelty-free, it's also totally invisible on the skin and has SPF 40. Read on for nine other great options, and check out our buying guide at the end to get the low-down on how to pick the best gel sunscreen on your own.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 10 Best Face Massage Tools in 2022 (Clarisonic, Esarora, and More)
    10 Best Face Massage Tools in 2022 (Clarisonic, Esarora, and More)
    We all worry about our skin, especially on our faces. Do you have concerns about sagging skin on your neck? Or dark circles under your eyes? Just about everyone over a certain age is worried about wrinkles and fine lines, and acne is a problem for many others. Facial massaging tools are one good way to address a variety of skin issues.These tools can come as simple rollers or electricity-powered gadgets and can do all sorts of great things for your lymphatic system. Our personal favorite was Roselyn Boutique's Jade Roller and Gua Sha Set because it provides an effective massage with very little effort on your part. Check out the rest of our top 10 favorites, and don't forget to read our buying guide to help you find your perfect match!
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 10 Best Shimmer Eyeshadows in 2021 (Too Faced, Hourglass, and More)
    Top 10 Best Shimmer Eyeshadows in 2021 (Too Faced, Hourglass, and More)
    If you’re looking to have more fun with your eye makeup, why not add some sparkle to it with shimmer eyeshadows? Shimmer eyeshadows contain glitters that reflect the light, adding a touch of shine to your eyes. These eyeshadows are very versatile; they can be used for minimal or bold makeup looks. Add just a touch of beige shimmer for a subtle highlight, or choose full-on glitter for a glam look!To make it easier for you, we’ve rounded up the best 10 shimmer eyeshadows in both bold and natural shades. Too Faced's Chocolate Gold Eyeshadow Palette is our top pick. With this palette, you'll have a ton of options to choose from! Read on to learn about the rest of the shimmer eyeshadows that made it to our list. If you’re looking for more information to help you decide, be sure to go through our buying guide.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 21 Best Japanese Shampoos for Color-Treated Hair in 2021
    Top 21 Best Japanese Shampoos for Color-Treated Hair in 2021
    Whether you dye your hair at home or go to a salon, it takes time, effort, and money to get the perfect color. You want it to last as long as possible, right? But did you know the right shampoo can keep your color from fading too fast? There are so many good Japanese shampoos for color-treated hair, like Belluga, DHC, and Napla. So how can you choose the best?You don't have to be a beautician! Our editors searched Japanese e-commerce sites such as Amazon, Rakuten, and Yahoo! Shopping for the best Japanese shampoos for color-treated hair available online. We then picked out the most popular products and tested them.With the advice of our expert, we focused on five things:Does it have good ingredients?How well does it wash?How well does it protect hair color?Does it leave hair smooth?Is it nice to use?We then ranked the products and put what we learned into a buying guide to help you choose the best Japanese shampoo for color-treated hair available online.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Top 10 Best Tanning Mitts in 2021 (St. Tropez, Tanologist, and More)
    Top 10 Best Tanning Mitts in 2021 (St. Tropez, Tanologist, and More)
    Want a better way to apply self tanning creams and lotions? Tanning mitts for your body and face can help you apply lotions more evenly and avoid a mess on your palms. There are also special mitts for your back and other hard-to-reach areas. If you've never used a tanning mitt before, our top 10 list and buying guide will demonstrate how to choose one. Be sure to check out our top pick, Stusgo's 4-Pack Self Tanning Mitt Applicator Kit. It has a little bit of everything, including an exfoliating glove and separate mitts for your body, face, and back. Also, keep reading to learn what to look for when selecting a tanning mitt such as the type and its durability.  
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Popular Articles

  • 10 Best Korean Night Creams in 2022 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Night Creams in 2022 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    If you're a K-beauty fanatic, you know that ingredients in Korean skincare can do a body good. When it comes to your nighttime routine, night creams are the perfect tool for ensuring a great beauty rest! That's why we went out of our way to research and compile a list of our absolute favorite Korean night creams.In our opinion, Neogen x Joan Kim VitaDuo Day and Night Cream is among the great Korean skincare products that provide great hydrating and moisturizing effects. Aside from being effective, it's also very innovative as it contains two creams - intensive day cream and night cream - in one container. Check out what more skincare products are a good addition to your night skincare routine! And if you're still full of questions, check out our buying guide with tips from aesthetician Devan Jesmer.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 8 Best Tried and True Japanese Hair Dyes in 2022 (Kao Liese, Palty, and More)
    8 Best Tried and True Japanese Hair Dyes in 2022 (Kao Liese, Palty, and More)
    Dyeing hair has been on-trend recently, but it can be expensive to do. Why not try an at-home kit instead of heading out to the salon? They're perfect for trying out different colors and getting a feel for dyeing hair in general. Japanese hair dyes, though formulated with dark, black Asian hair in mind, can also work great for other types of hair, but always make sure to conduct a patch test in case!To figure out what's best to use, we evaluated and tested eight of the most popular hair dyes found in drugstores in Japan and e-commerce sites. We tested them based on: three criteria: how vivid the color washow gentle the dye was on hairhow long the color lastedOur favorite was Liese Prettia Bubble Hair Color; check out why below!
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 10 Best Korean Toners for Oily Skin in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Toners for Oily Skin in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    Looking for a toner that will nourish your skin and keep oil at bay? Try a Korean toner! Unlike some toners that can be overly moisturizing or drying, many Korean toners are full of ingredients that will gently exfoliate, soothe, and hydrate your skin. And if you have oily skin, you know that you sorely need a toner that reduces excess oil while balancing your skin's pH level. That's why we've done our research and compiled a list of the best Korean toners for oily skin. Right on top of that list is COSRX's AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner! It's a two-in-one toner that helps exfoliate and hydrate the skin. Don't forget to check other products in our list and use our buying guide with tips from aesthetician Devan Jesmer to help you choose one on your own as well!
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 10 Best Korean Facial Cleansers in 2022 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Facial Cleansers in 2022 (Dermatologist-Reviewed)
    Shocked and worried about the appearance of fine lines? Or perhaps you're annoyed with how much scrubbing you need to do to get that water-proof mascara off? Stress no more - Korean facial cleansers are here to save the day! Not only do they remove makeup effectively, leaving your face clean and smooth, but they also have the power to do so much more for the skin. They can even prevent signs of aging. Consider The Face Shop's Rice Water Bright Foaming Cleanser, which removes dead skin cells, hydrates, and soothes the skin all at the same time! We've picked out the best of the best Korean facial cleansers online and included a buying guide in case you're still unsure what this first step in the world-famous Korean skincare routine entails. Here's to great-looking skin! 
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 10 Best Korean Sunscreens for Oily Skin in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Sunscreens for Oily Skin in 2021 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    Frustrated with all the sunscreens with rich consistency that won't sink into your skin and make your skin feel even oilier than it already is? Consider using a Korean sunscreen! Most have a lightweight consistency that can absorb quickly into your skin and provide optimal protection against the sun. Besides, some even contain ingredients that can help regulate oil production to balance out your oily skin and leave it feeling much more refreshed.After combing the internet, we've found 10 Korean sunscreens that can work like a charm for your oily skin. One of them is COSRX's Aloe Soothing Sun Cream, which is formulated with aloe leaf extract to soothe and lightly moisturize the skin. There are other products that are equally effective on our list, so give them a look as well!  And check out our buying guide and additional tips from aesthetician Devan Jesmer.
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 10 Best Korean Serums for Soft, Glowing Skin in 2022 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    10 Best Korean Serums for Soft, Glowing Skin in 2022 (Aesthetician-Reviewed)
    Want to make your skin glow? Korean serums are mild, lightweight, and contain a high concentration of active ingredients that can help all skin types. Some common skin-nourishing ingredients are ginseng, green tea, and aloe vera. Korean skincare also utilizes more unique ingredients, like snail mucin, placenta, and propolis! Check out our buying guide, which we prepared with the help of aesthetician Devan Jesmer, where you'll find all the necessary information regarding Korean serums, and our top 10 highly recommended products. Innisfree's Green Tea Seed Serum is our top-ranking product because it absorbs quickly, soothes irritated skin, and prevents signs of aging. If you want to know more, don't forget to check out the rest products on our list!
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • 9 Best Tried and True Japanese Body Creams in 2022 - Beauty Expert-Reviewed
    9 Best Tried and True Japanese Body Creams in 2022 - Beauty Expert-Reviewed
    Browsing for the best Japanese body creams can be a tough task. What you want is a body cream that hydrates (possibly even more than a high-end brand), a low price tag, and no shady ingredients. And while the search can be fun, but it can also be time-consuming, especially if you don’t read Japanese.To save you the headache, we ordered the 9 most popular body creams from Japan’s e-commerce giants (such as @cosme, Amazon, and Rakuten) and tested for the following:HydrationFragranceIngredientsStickinessFeelKeep on reading to find out more!
    Cosmetics and skincare
  • Popular Expert Picks

    Search by Category